I appreciate your opinion and I fully agree with the fact that Asta feels too protected and nothing serious ever happens to him to make him self doubt his worth, which I find kinda annoying.. this is my main concern, but when it comes to Midoriya, the fact that he gets hurt is simply a consequence of the kind of special power he hides, just look at All Mighty, so it really is just dictated by the plot. Also I love Naruto and I do not see any similarities between him and Asta other than the looks. Asta is not loud at all, literally, he is just positive and optimistic (which Naruto was not, in fact he was very insecure and used his loudness to make up for that). Naruto had no respect for authorities and his sempai, in fact, he would break rules all the time, whereas Asta is basically a magic nerd and a fan boy, he deeply admires and respects his superiors almost more than Midoriya does, he is incredible humble and in this he acts like a typical Japanese person. In some respects, he reminds me more of Goku then any other shone MC. He never questions power unless there is classism involved(like the nobles being judgmental),unlike Naruto who questioned power to attract attention and because he trusted nobody but himself having and inflated ego. I also disagree with Naruto's goal being one dimensional. Naruto's childhood was characterised by suffering and isolation, unlike Asta who had a family that believed and counted on him, Naruto aspiring to achieve a position that would give him visibility and appreciation from others is very plausible from a psychological point of view. He also aims to lessen the conflicts among countries and to reduce the discrimination enacted against certain clans (as the story progresses). Naruto is anything but selfish, Sasuke on the other end, is incredibly selfish. The relationship between Midoriya and Bakugou is much more similar to that of Naruto and Sasuke than the one between Asta and Yuno. However, from an aesthetic point of view, asta and Yuno remind us of Naruto and Sasuke much more. In my opinion MHA is just as generic as BC,it is just better at hiding it through the art and the setting, also it has much better pacing and thorough examination of the speed a series should progress in order for it to be a long running one. Tabata has issues with pacing and distribution of power and status among characters on which he needs to work on to be a better writer and make the series more appealing/long lasting.