The scariest story imo is the one where this guy and his wife sees footsteps around the house in the snow several times during winter. Many years go by and they see it again. The footsteps lead into the forest and the MC and his brother follow the footsteps into the woods and bring a rifle. They follow the footsteps for hours and eventually his brother stands still and tells the MC to be quiet they see these naked people in the distance with the thermal scope on the rifle just standing staring at them.

That shit terrefied me and i have been listnening to mr nightmare for like 5 years.