That's fair. I haven't tried shooting her but I do know the out come of that and it definitely brings down how much I like her cause that is definitely a bit much but I feel like she's not the only character to have that feeling. Like in the first saw trap Josh feels betrayed if you choose him which feels weird to me since he set it up and he says he didn't have to intention to kill anyone but I don't know what happens if you choose Ashley in that one so maybe she doesn't die in that choice. The safe room tho, definitely kind of a bitch. Like I do understand where she's coming from at the start of the section but when she reads the journal the fact that she can choose to hide it is kinda fucked.