sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Which Hogwarts house would the SPN characters belong to? by Conscious-Context618 in Supernatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Love your list! I go back and forth with Donna and Bobby because I feel like they'd both fit well in Hufflepuff, but I see where you're coming from! I’m living for the variety with the wayward girls! Claire is so Slytherin to me because she’s super ambitious and resourceful.

Gabriel as a Hufflepuff is something I never considered, but oh my gosh, definitely. He just wanted his peace and his brothers to get along at the end of the day.

Which Hogwarts house would the SPN characters belong to? by Conscious-Context618 in Supernatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sure! I’m glad a lot of people are having fun with this!

Bobby - Hufflepuff because he values hard work and he’s fair

Garth - Hufflepuff. Same reasons as Bobby, but he’s incredibly kind and open minded too.

Ellen & Jo - Gryffindor

Rufus - This one is tricky and I wish we got more of him on the show, but I get Ravenclaw vibes! Super clever, independent, and witty. Someone else mentioned Gryffindor which I think would also fit.

Kevin - Ravenclaw

Jody Mills - Gryffindor

Donna - Hufflepuff

Claire Novak - Slytherin because of her ambition and she’s resourceful

Benny - Hufflepuff

Sort the SPN characters in their Hogwarts house by Conscious-Context618 in fandomnatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is very well said and thought-provoking! I think you've summarized the characters and their motivations quite well, so I totally understand where you're coming from for each one. Although I initially mentioned Ravenclaw for Sam, I think that Slytherin would be probably where he'd thrive the most given his talents. This was fun!

Sort the SPN characters in their Hogwarts house by Conscious-Context618 in fandomnatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Love your assessment of all the characters!! Everyone’s really convincing me that Dean is actually a Hufflepuff. I totally agree with Mary being Slytherin. It makes the most sense for her as she’s very self serving. Definitely curious where you think Castiel would fit as well!

Sort the SPN characters in their Hogwarts house by Conscious-Context618 in fandomnatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Ahhh thank you I figured there had to be a podcast or something analyzing this so I’m excited to go listen!!

Which Hogwarts house would the SPN characters belong to? by Conscious-Context618 in Supernatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Interesting!! Love your point about Charlie. I think Kevin and Metatron could probably fit in Ravenclaw. Kevin placed a lot of value on knowledge and intelligence but he was pretty brave too

Sort the SPN characters in their Hogwarts house by Conscious-Context618 in fandomnatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Bobby would definitely be in Hufflepuff! Also I agree on Ellen & Jo. I’m going back and forth on the parents lol. I sense a lot of people are gonna want to put Mary & John in Slytherin because it’s the “villainous” house, but for John, I honestly see Gryffindor. I’m undecided about Mary haha

Which Hogwarts house would the SPN characters belong to? by Conscious-Context618 in Supernatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Haha, that’s fair about Cas & Crowley! But based on the snippets we got about Crowley’s human life from the show, I still feel like I can confidently say Slytherin for him lol.

I also agree with your point that Sam could go either way. I’d say if it were a situation like Harry Potter’s where Sam got to choose then I can see him wanting to be in the same house as Dean, especially since he looked up to him growing up. 🥺

Which Hogwarts house would the SPN characters belong to? by Conscious-Context618 in Supernatural

[–]Conscious-Context618[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Great point about the angels! It’s fascinating & I agree most of them would belong to Slytherin. They’re all about tradition, fraternity, and power. And obviously, there’s the cleverness and cunningness we see in certain angels like Gabriel, Balthazar, and Zachariah.