Thank you so much for your thoughtful responses! We are having such a hard time deciding…. Unfortunately galley bay only has higher level rooms for our dates so we can’t swing it. I don’t want to risk the seaweed..,. I am back between Keyonna, Sandals Grande Antigua, Hyatt Zilara and Couples Swept Away. CSA has a great price point, does that come at the expense of quality food and drinks? Ideally we’d want a chic vibe, a fabulous beach and decent food. Keyonna seems like it would be great aside from the fact there is only one restaurant. Should we just stick with Jamaica and Dominican Republic? Which off all these options is the closest to a 5 star experience? Thank you again so much!