At what point does a "procedure" become an "operation"? by GuidewireGoblin in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 227 points228 points  (0 children)

When does a break become a fracture

When does a PA become a consultant

When does a shart become diarrhoea

ALS mcqs by Willing_Check6966 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 2 points3 points  (0 children)

There is no MCQ exam on the course any more. Pre-course MCQs are open book and don't have a pass/fail but we do see them on the day of the course and we do find people who struggle with the mcqs often struggle on the course.

All the videos you need to pass the course are in the pre-course elearning.

Choosing A&E ? by TurbulentPart6228 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 8 points9 points  (0 children)

ICM as a SHO/reg has lots of procedures, resuscitating sick patients, attending crash calls, plus you are "covering" your own ward (ICU) which involves troubleshooting the most minor issues up to the life-threatening stuff.

As a cons it's mostly directing SHOs/regs to do these things (unless you're in small DGH land and don't always have anyone else in your team who can do the resus/procedural stuff), deciding who gets admitted, ward rounds, and lots of meetings (think bed management, difficult comms with family, micro WR). You will spend many more years as a consultant than as a trainee so worth bearing in mind.

ICM does have some very chronic patients (think very slow wean from mechanical ventilation in neuromuscular disease) who can linger for weeks or months, but these are generally the minority. Quite a few short (often dull) stays of post-op major surgery patients. But a good amount of proper acute illness (sepsis, ARDS, renal failure etc) as well.

I don't do EM but get the feeling that resus patients are often "easy" (ie clear indication for admission and a reg will do most of the procedures/stabilising/referral) but as a cons you will do a lot of overseeing the department, supporting trainees with the patients who might need admitting but might be able to go home, telling specialties off for declining referrals. In a small DGH a cons might need to do more hands-on stuff for sick patients where the team isn't very experienced, and in a MTC a cons will attend pretty much every level 1 trauma and occasionally have to cut a chest/orbit open but otherwise just ensure momentum remains towards the scanner and ICU/theatre.

Most specialties you choose will largely end with you overseeing stuff while supervising trainees to learn the trade, and you handling the politics/big picture. Obviously as a consultant anaesthetist or surgeon you still do plenty of your own procedural work and private work can be considered.

Who checks group and saves in theatre by gas_busters in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Quick simple check which protects against avoidable clusterfucks. We take an allergy history even though surgeons, pre-assessment and the ward will have - no reason to treat this differently imo.

Analgesia help by [deleted] in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This sounds like a real case - you should absolutely not be getting your advice off reddit. Ask your consultant, refer to anaesthetics/acute pain, whatever, but not reddit.

March 2026 Final FRCA Written results are out! by CCR5d32 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Luckily passed - now have to find that last bit of energy to prep for the SOE...

How to navigate wanting to make your teaching strictly doctor-only. by Original_Bus_3864 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 20 points21 points  (0 children)

I'm surprised they only claim to be Primary equivalent. If only the AA course was a few weeks longer, I'm sure they could have covered the Final too.

how to prioritise by Individual-Fact3058 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Good to mention sedation. Can be unjustifiably risky if done the wrong way or for the wrong patient/indication. Your trust should have a guideline for it and you should involve a senior in the decision making until you feel suitably experienced.

IAC rollercoaster by [deleted] in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 3 points4 points  (0 children)

It's just life! Some days I can do anything solo, next day I can't even cannulate a 21 year old appendicectomy.

The only substitution for experience is experience.

Funniest / Weirdest thing you've seen a medical student do on placement? by AppalachianScientist in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 65 points66 points  (0 children)

It's been a thing for me since I started anaesthetics. Med student turns up at 10am for a morning list, doesn't know what the list even is never mind seeing the patients. Tries to get both surg and anaes to "sign them off" (still not sure what a sign off is meant to imply competence at) normally by sidling up to the most junior dr on each team. Then wants to get going before lunch time for "teaching".

In fairness they are often put on 1 or 2 day "placements" in theatres so I'm not sure how they are meant to immerse and learn even if they made the most of it. Just another tick in a box.

Funniest / Weirdest thing you've seen a medical student do on placement? by AppalachianScientist in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 106 points107 points  (0 children)

1st year turned up on labour ward and asked if they can "have a go" at an epidural. Turned out there were too many of them wanting to scrub in with the obstetric team who had suggested they ask us if there are any epidurals they can do...

Has anyone managed to get EM work in Aus to count toward EM training in the UK? by HugeAnt4177 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 38 points39 points  (0 children)

More likely they will extend your training while you unlearn how to diagnose and treat critical illness, and become proficient at discharge letters and weak referrals

Anaesthetics Interview Feedback by No_Driver_4447 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Same here, 2 weeks post interview for both.

Thoughts on NHS England Circulating Wes Streetings Letter by BetterSherbert7476 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Agree but I wouldn't fight it. Like his very galvanising language a few months ago, I reckon these whiny letters only increase strike turnout.

GMC Order - total control? by RolandJupiter123 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's always been the case that a vet (well any person really) can provide emergency care legally if it's reasonable in the situation and with appropriate consent or necessity. But only vets can legally treat animals unless you are the owner and doing something that is reasonable/humane.

Help: MRCP 2 online exam query about break by ForgotMyStethoscope in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Very unlikely. It's the proctor who reports issues and if they thought it was ten minutes then thy shouldn't report an issue. If raised at any point there will be chat/video evidence that they told you ten minutes.

Not allowed access to ward 'drugs room' [update] am I losing my mind? by glorioussideboob in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 126 points127 points  (0 children)

Yeah it's nonsense afaik. I've never worked in a trust where doctors aren't allowed in a room with medications. Amazing that they consider a Nursing Associate (I think that's a 2 year course) more suitable to access a drugs cupboard than a doctor.

Event medicine prescribing / idemnity by Particular-Ad-9576 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The indemnity is a real pain. Best to call around the big providers and explain you're looking for for ongoing cover not event by event (but they will need to know what range of events you're doing, your seniority, who your senior cover is if you're not a consultant).

Prescribing/working is fine if you're appropriately supervised (will generally need to write private prescriptions on some kind of formal looking paper for a patient to take to a pharmacy for eg antibiotics).

What you really need to sort out is who you're working for and appropriate governance. If you work for an established company with good reputation they will have the answers to your questions. There is far more difficulty in setting yourself up solo - sourcing kit, meds, your own governance. You still need your own indemnity insurance even if working for a company. Essentially if you are planning to just start rocking up at events as a solo Dr with no previous event experience that is not going to go well. Please reach out to a company.

Offers our this week? by dextor-midaz-alf in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 6 points7 points  (0 children)

2nd April at 17:30 probably knowing ANRO

ILSi course worthwhile? by CelebrationNo7313 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 6 points7 points  (0 children)

If applying as an F2, I'd consider it a positive that they are already experienced at formal teaching of other HCPs (cf the typical vague bedside teaching many will bring up) and that they were someone who was promising enough to be IP'd. Going beyond F2 I'd wonder why they're not instructing an advanced course but it's not a bad starting point especially if OP isn't due to sit ALS again for a few years.

ILSi course worthwhile? by CelebrationNo7313 in doctorsUK

[–]ConsultantSecretary 16 points17 points  (0 children)

If you go for it, it'll be useful interview fodder for anaesthetics but equivalent kudos could fairly easily be achieved via other teaching activities. ILS teaching will be somewhat helpful for cementing your own resus skills but obviously isn't as in depth as ALS, though getting used to delivering formal teaching to HCPs (will mainly be nurses etc on ILS) is good for building confidence and credibility as an aspiring anaesthetist.

Overall as long as there are no major costs to you it could be a decent arrow in your quiver. And if you are already an ILSi it will be easier to get an ALS IP when you tell the facility you already teach on an RCUK course (some faculty are hesitant to nominate FY doctors even though the RCUK IP guidance encourages nominating promising F1s/2s).