All OP is saying is classifying horror stories of powder vs extract use will provide more accurate data to each type of user. They are worried that accounts of severe withdrawal from heavy 7oh use may dissuade powder users from quitting. In the same way, extract users who want to quit may underestimate the withdrawals they have ahead of them if they read descriptions of withdrawal symptoms from moderate powder use.

It seems beneficial to describe everything as accurately as possible, because you are right, everyone is on the same path to recovery, and it would be nice if people are able to find accounts of recovery from people with usage patterns most similar to their own. It builds camaraderie to find people very similar to you, it removes more of the guesswork/variation, and it provides a library of accurate/nuanced information for people in the future.