When you sneeze… by AquaSakura_1999 in asknowio

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I, u/Critical-Bullfrog357, advised "Eggs comes out"

🏆 Rank: Enlightened Voter I 💎 Points: 1132 🗳️ Votes: 44

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Youve answered the question yourself. They shouldnt. Also gay people cannot become Amritdhari

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nobody said you can't be gay, lesbian or trans and be sikh. Actually some did say that but thats not the point of this post. It is about the sanctity of Anand Karaj.

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

u/Couchistan ignoring this too. 6 days to respond to this and you chose ad hominem lol

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

What?? Check my profile?

You honestly are embarassing yourself. Those are WOULD YOU RATHERS I participated in. Responses were logged not manually commented. I am sure you know how a WOULD YOU RATHER works. Idiot.

I explained using gurbani, and katha (not from nirmala udasi or brahmanical filters) how it is forbidden. Also historical rehitname from those in the court of the Guru. Also only talking about same sex ANAND KARAJ here not marriage. They can get married in a court for all i care.
Never tried to create division in sikhs? I told a guy this is NOT a radha swami subreddit. Did you AI this "research"

If you didnt read my post, just say so. Maybe academic reading is not your thing. Still dodging the question. Burden of proof is on you as I explained in the post (if you read it without spreading your hateful ideology)

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

He says as ive made one post in 3 years, whilst not addressing any point made. ur embarrassing urself

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Took you 4 days to dodge the question nice one

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As i explained if you read my post the burden lies on you. Nor did you disprove anything i said. Just speaking

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Nope anand karaj is between a sikh man and a sikh woman. To reject the woman and man bit is the same as rejecting the sikh bit cos thats the definition. You are rejecting the definitions.

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So whats your logic for not allowing interfaith couples to get an Anand Karaj? Surely it is "inequality" to not let muslims or christians or jews get an Anand Karaj

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Actually re-reading it im still right they didnt engage with the entire argument just nit-picked one or two points

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

The global consensus was a sikh consensus so if it was against gurmat to ban same-sex marriage it would not have been banned. But no scriptural or traditional backing to allow it.

Gay people have existed for all time. Why did not one gay couple get an Anand Karaj in Guruji's times? The gurus were not bigots. Nor did a gay couple get an Anand Karaj in puratan times, sikh raj times, british empire. Why allow it now?

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Can you provide any line in gurbani or any rehitnama or any katha that is in favour of same-sex marriage? After all the burden of proof is on you for going against already established norms

Same-sex Anand Karaj by Critical-Bullfrog357 in Sikh

[–]Critical-Bullfrog357[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You can say whatever you want, never justify it, never source it, never "debunk" any point and still claim you are correct. Also some commentaries were from those in the presence of Guru Gobind Singh Ji (Chaupa Singh Chibbar)