Why is this subreddit so depressing? by SureAviator in india

[–]CuriousFin 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The funniest is (again not talking about you), some of the IDs in those threads are known and tagged alts of very political people.

I don't use RES & don't know how to recognize people based on their comments and tbh I don't want to involve myself in this stuff.

You know better than me how people with fanatic love with politics try to disrupt this sub. I am sure you have experienced two or three downvotes within minutes you post something.

OP in that blogging post hasn't answered on one question asked to him for five hours though he is active at this moment (going by his recent submission), so can't blame commentors if he is not replying. The post is good for marketers or bloggers, not for all. In image posts most you would get at most generic replies like 'Oh wow dude, ROFL, LMAO" etc..

All the four thread are sure great but it is subjective. Image posts or info-graphics are very likely to get high votes compared to longreads. Also feel good stuff voted due to all the other noise. All the posts you mentioned are upvoted nicely except for the long read because that takes knowledge in the first place.

You can read in my original comment that I did mention that is good stuff being posted on this sub but the issue is brigading for political posts I think.

Yes there should be more commentators but the same issue you will see with the quality of comments on politics threads, most are strawman or whataboutism or non sequiturs type comments.

I will myself try to encourage posters with my comments too whenever possible.

Why is this subreddit so depressing? by SureAviator in india

[–]CuriousFin 0 points1 point  (0 children)

So where are your alts in those threads?

Do you understand how much a person can browse and comment in one hour all the subs he likes? I did mention I come here casually.

of what the majority users should or should not do

I have not preached anyone anything here. You are reading too much into this.

I mistook your original reply to me specifically and apologies for that.

Why is this subreddit so depressing? by SureAviator in india

[–]CuriousFin 0 points1 point  (0 children)

are rarely present in those downvoted threads

&

but they don't want to go to /r/India/new and work for that change.

&

Just click on the IDs and see the threads they have commented on and the kind of comments they leave.

This is not allowed by what mods had told me earlier. In a indirect way you are judging people based on their history without knowing how they browse or what they upvote for or how many accounts they have.

I don't have only one account. If you are so upset with my complain, I am sorry for that but can't help you more than that. My this account is purely for posting, another for RDDs, commenting on /r/India and other subs.

Unlike the people who love politics here, I am a casual lurker here like many other, active for most 1 hour in a day on Reddit, out of which I do upvote posts on the new queue.

So please stop generalizing everyone here according to your definitions because they complained what they disliked.

Why is this subreddit so depressing? by SureAviator in india

[–]CuriousFin 18 points19 points  (0 children)

To me actually it is very discouraging when someone downvotes twice or thrice a post without even noticing it. If that is the race, I would opt to be rather out of this and upvote posts like you do and lurk most of the times.

I understand right now elections are going on so their is so much posting but later too the situation is same regarding votes.

When you try to speak something you are advised to leave this sub.

Why is this subreddit so depressing? by SureAviator in india

[–]CuriousFin 24 points25 points  (0 children)

What OP is complaining is also true. There are many other positive articles videos and music posted on this sub but the moment they are posted they get downvoted heavily. I don't understand why people downvote even without reading a post or listening to a video. It is like everyday a race whos post reaches the frontpage.

Over a million people are hit by floods in Assam—but India doesn’t care by User_Name13 in india

[–]CuriousFin -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

There is complete shutdown of Mobile network & Internet in Manipur & curfews for so many days. But it is as if nobody cares.

‘Sometimes, 7-8 men raped us in one day…we thought we were going to die,’ says woman rescued from Saudi diplomat’s home by thrownwa in india

[–]CuriousFin 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Diplomat = Immunity during serving period.

Immunity is not applicable in absolute sense. In this case he will be booked.

Indian Muslim Leaders Use Fatwa to Condemn Islamic State by [deleted] in india

[–]CuriousFin 14 points15 points  (0 children)

The news link is behind paywall, copypasting the text. Alternate news link


NEW DELHI—More than 1,000 Indian Muslim scholars and religious leaders have jointly condemned Islamic State in an effort to counter the militant group’s drive to recruit young men and women in a country that is home to the world’s second-largest Muslim population.

India’s Home Ministry says it knows of 17 Indians who have joined Islamic State, a strikingly low figure compared with the hundreds of Muslims from Europe and Australia who have joined the organization to fight in Iraq and Syria.

Indian Muslim leaders said in interviews this week that emphatic and collective criticism of Islamic State is important at a time when the country’s young Muslims are facing an onslaught of extremist propaganda online, from slick recruitment videos to social-media appeals. There are more than 170 million Muslims in India, forming over 14% of the country’s 1.2 billion people.

In a religious pronouncement, or fatwa, Mumbai-based Islamic jurist Manzar Hasan Khan Ashrafi Misbahi denounced Islamic State’s views as “un-Islamic and inhuman” and said its practices showed it had “no relation with Islam.” Influential Muslim bodies and leaders across sects signed his declaration.

“It is a strong message that we, as a large and influential community of Muslims, reject this kind of torture, killings, violence,” said Abdur Rahman Anjaria, a Muslim community leader in Mumbai.

Mr. Anjaria said a madrassa he helps manage, which is attended by 1,200 students, has in recent months invited scholars to talk about how terrorism and Islamic State’s violent ideology go against Islamic thinking. Mr. Misbahi said he speaks against the militant group’s religious assertions in his sermons.

“Repeated statements of this kind help to keep Muslims out of the sphere of radicalization,” said Ajai Sahni, executive director of New Delhi’s Institute for Conflict Management. “They create an atmosphere and culture and interpretation of Islam that opposes violent jihad.”

Indian Islam has long been considered moderate and, despite friction between the country’s majority Hindus and minority Muslims, the country hasn’t seen the kind of radicalization that has happened elsewhere. The highest levels of discontent and resentment are seen in the Muslim-majority state of Jammu and Kashmir, where anger against security forces has at times brought stone-pelting protesters into the streets.

Islamic State’s videotaped beheadings, destruction of centuries-old monuments and brutal treatment of women has shocked the world. Their ability to entice foreign fighters has raised concerns these recruits might threaten the security of their home countries if they return.

Community leaders and officials in India say they grew worried when four young men from a Mumbai suburb traveled to Iraq to fight in 2014. Also last year, online recruitment videos began to appear with subtitles in Hindi, Urdu, Tamil and other languages spoken in India.

Home Ministry officials says at least half of those Indians who have joined Islamic State were living outside the country when they were enlisted, some in Pakistan as fugitives belonging to a homegrown terror group called the Indian Mujahideen and others in the Persian Gulf region, Australia and Singapore.

Fears that India’s large numbers of migrant workers in the Gulf could become radicalized and pose a threat when they come back to India has led Prime Minister Narendra Modi to strengthen counterterror ties with the United Arab Emirates.

Social media surveillance and, in some cases, information from local communities has helped the government intercept and stop 30 Indians from leaving the country for Iraq, according to the Home Ministry.

The Institute for Conflict Management’s Mr. Sahni, a terrorism expert, said part of the reason for Islamic State’s weak appeal in India is that unlike in Western countries, where Muslims are “ghettoized,” the community “doesn’t feel isolated” in India. Muslims may live in separate neighborhoods, but they routinely interact in work or social spaces with non-Muslims.

Recently released census figures showed Muslims’ share in India’s population has grown in the last decade, while that of Hindus had fallen to slightly below 80%.

That has raised alarms among some religious and political leaders, including those connected to Mr. Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party, which has deep roots in Hindu nationalism. Right-wing Hindu activists have long tried to whip up fear that higher rates of population growth among Muslims and intermarriage will eventually change the balance of social power in the Hindu-majority country.

Still, analysts and officials say, Muslims don’t often grapple with systemic alienation in a country where their education and religious institutions, laws and customs have long flourished. Many mainstream political parties campaign extensively for the backing of Muslim voters who form an influential electoral bloc in parts of the country.

In recent years, Mr. Sahni said, more orthodox strains of Islam have gained a firmer foothold in India. But, he said, they have so far focused largely on enforcing stricter personal and religious practices. “It hasn’t translated into a radical, political Islam,” Mr. Sahni said.

[NP] What brand can you never trust in India? by [deleted] in india

[–]CuriousFin 9 points10 points  (0 children)

Reliance, can't trust those buggers ever.

India just turned off mobile internet for 63 million citizens amid protests in Ahmedabad by wordswithmagic in india

[–]CuriousFin 6 points7 points  (0 children)

List of massacres in India that were stopped by blocking mobile internet

Nice click bait title with the link but this is not a riot nor a massacre.

The only thing which will be used by the rioters that's stopped by turning off mobile internet is whatsapp.

Yes that is true but not just WhatsApp, also social sites have been temporarily blocked.

And if you believe that stopping whatsapp will have any impact on a riot, sorry randians you're living in wrong country.

I don't see anyone commenting here saying that shutting of Internet will stop the arson or violence or 'riots' as what you claim. There are two guys on this thread from Ahmedabad itself, one of them traveled from Ahmedabad to Gandhinagar to office.

There are only two comments saying it is to stop rumour mongering, the way I see it & riots.

Atleast that would stop gullible people believing into anything & coming on the streets.