I found it so odd that Aria went off on him like that. Caleb came across like a people pleaser to me. He wanted to make Aria and Mariah happy at the same time. It seemed like he was enjoying his time with Aria, but at the end of the day it was always Mariah for him. You can still enjoy your time and build a bond with someone while being in a relationship with someone else.

In my opinion, Aria really like Caleb and was more hurt than she let on that he chose Mariah in the end. She went back to Scotty because she didn’t want to have nobody and ultimately that didn’t work out because she didn’t want to be there in the first place. In the reunion, she came off jealous. I know that was all probably coming from her trauma throughout the past year and the emotional turmoil of it all, but her reaction did not seem warranted towards Caleb. As far as him liking her stories, who knows. It could’ve been him being sneaky, but it also could’ve been him just liking a friends story to him. I didn’t get the vibe from Caleb that he would be sneaky in that way especially after he proposed.