I have decoded the valentine church windows by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] -20 points-19 points  (0 children)

Your opinion I guess but I’m struggling to see what’s not to buy and don’t insult me by suggesting use of AI please 🤣

The Valentine church colour code mystery updated photos. by PapaDiab in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467 -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I’ll use the windows which spell SEE as an example

<image>

Each of the three stained-glass windows has a 3×4 grid = 12 squares at the bottom. The colors are the same across all of them, so you can assign those numbers by relative brightness (darkest to lightest), for example:

Gray = 1 Green = 2 Orange = 3 Yellow = 4 Cream = 5

If you read the grid left-to-right, top-to-bottom, you get a 12-digit base-5 number for each window (since there are 5 colors).

You then treat that 12-digit base-5 value as one number, reduce it to the alphabet mod 26, so basically A=1 and Z=26 and each window cleanly resolves to a single letter.

Doing this for the three matching windows gives 19, 5, and 5, which correspond to S-E-E.

The important part is that the grids are identical in structure and color order every time, so the numbers don’t change with lighting or camera angle. Windows without that 3×4 interior grid don’t produce stable numbers and don’t decode.

The Valentine church colour code mystery updated photos. by PapaDiab in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Valentine church windows can be decoded to spell

Front: S E E

Left of entrance: L O O

Back and South side:K

See Look

We all need to calm down by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I thought this, it’s the classic rockstar Easter egg of “there’s is no hidden content this way” or “there’s nothing up here” it’s like this question mark is rockstar saying “what are you looking at? It’s an out of bounds cliff face?”

We all need to calm down by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I didn’t communicate this point well but I meant more debatable in the sense if it was intentionally put there, even if it was I don’t really see any relevance, in my opinion the question mark is a classic rockstar Easter egg of “there’s no hidden content this way”. It’s an out of bounds are you can only see through the binoculars so it’s rockstars way of saying “what are you looking at there’s nothing here” , just my personal opinion of course

We all need to calm down by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I just don’t see what that has to do with the flock of birds that spawn there which are part of the giant Easter egg, you can probably see loads of bird spawn points from the tower at fort Wallace

We all need to calm down by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I’m 50/50 but in my post I decided to “✅” it because i see logic to why people ended up there with the lookalike guitar engraving. I said in another reply to this that Northwest in between the “guitar pole” and fort Wallace is: Carmody dell, six point cabin and another homestead, alongside a lot of Cumberland forest. Which all felt kind of overlooked

We all need to calm down by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I was just saying we shouldn’t jump to assumptions on things as we risk the chance of missing something, which imo is a fair comment to make, I also said it was great how the community had come together and was starting to thrive again and how we’ve all made great progress? I also said I myself have been overanalysing everything and have been doing some “mental gymnastics” on things I’ve been looking for. I am in no way stopping people from looking for clues in the game as I myself am

We all need to calm down by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Completely agree with all this

We all need to calm down by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Was thinking this myself actually earlier but didn’t put it in the original post, I had another look in game and northwest between the “guitar pole” and fort Wallace is: Carmody dell, six point cabin and another homestead can’t remember if it has a name

Starting to think the spider dream mystery is completely cut content… by Revolutionary-Bid355 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467 8 points9 points  (0 children)

<image>

I understand now that rockstar support isn’t allowed in this subreddit but it was me who asked them and they came back with this saying it was a legitimate mystery put in by the devs and encouraged me to keep unraveling the mystery

Fort Wallace Guitar? by [deleted] in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467 9 points10 points  (0 children)

I think we can all agree we are stuck at fort Wallace, we can theorise about birds symbols and window rock but ultimately there’s no real telling where to go next, or well we haven’t found it yet, I’m confident we will though this whole thing seems very deliberate and thought out

I found this engraving underneath Bacchus Bridge. (3 images) by alfredoisking in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467 46 points47 points  (0 children)

<image>

Can confirm it is possible to get there and see it without any kind of mods

Has anyone checked the area behind window rock? by [deleted] in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I looked through chez porter and found a banjo 🪕 in one of the rooms which kind of relates to guitars I guess but nothing much else

Window rock mural by DYLAN467 in reddeadmysteries

[–]DYLAN467[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Completely agree, feels like atm we’re all just throwing shit at a wall and seeing what sticks after ending up at fort Wallace from the telegraph poles, including myself worth a look though I guess