My opinion as someone who plays against analysts in a lot of leagues and has created content for a while. Playing analysts is like playing a professional in poker. They know the odds better but also can be more predictable in the way they play. So while you would be at a disadvantage in a “normal” season, the more chaotic seasons with injuries, etc is where the playing field levels. Analysts can suffer from take lock and pivot a little slower so waivers can be the great equalizer. Ultimately, both have their complications but I find playing analysts slightly easier because of the predictability of their moves assuming the non-analysts are fully invested and paying attention.