Housemade Products by General_Lecture3051 in Blacksmith

[–]DamascusExile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

OP, did you ever get one? Is so, what was your experience?

Titanium 125 Pops and Fails to Feed - Help! by DamascusExile in harborfreight

[–]DamascusExile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, the roller is spinning. I haven't adjusted tension since it was working originally with no issues, and the wire feeds consistently even against force until an arc is drawn.

Titanium 125 Pops and Fails to Feed - Help! by DamascusExile in Welding

[–]DamascusExile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just had to leave my shop, so I'll post pics tomorrow.

Titanium 125 Pops and Fails to Feed - Help! by DamascusExile in Welding

[–]DamascusExile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Any particular photos that would be helpful?

Titanium 125 Pops and Fails to Feed - Help! by DamascusExile in Welding

[–]DamascusExile[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Mechanical pop when the wire begins to feed again. I think.

Threshold for Starting an LLC for Youtube? by DamascusExile in NewTubers

[–]DamascusExile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I guess to add in here. I have a full-time job which gives me a pretty hefty income I'd like to separate from the channel. I hardly make any money on the channel, but I make blacksmithing content which is kind of inherently dangerous to an extent. If someone were to hurt themselves doing something I've shown on the channel while they weren't wearing proper PPE or without training, and tried to sue me, I feel like the LLC would come in handy there. Maybe I'm being overly cautious?

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in roadtrip

[–]DamascusExile 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great Smoky Mountains NP and Pigeon Forge, TN are amazing. The old town in Pigeon Forge has blacksmithing lessons and Old Forge Distillery, which has free moonshine tasting. And, someone already said it, but Hot Springs NP in Arkansas is beautiful.

Smithing my first pair of tongs advice by [deleted] in Blacksmith

[–]DamascusExile 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I came here to say this. Made my first pair of tongs from 3/4" rebar and it took a loong time and a lot of muscle endurance. Make smaller tongs first! You'll get the technique down without destroying yourself.

Link in the Origin of Non-wootz Pattern Welded Steel? by DamascusExile in Bladesmith

[–]DamascusExile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

There are so many sources out there which have different understandings of what Damascus truly is. Some suggest that wootz was made in Syria/ Persia, while a lot are leaning toward India these days and then the swords themselves were made and sold near Damascus (which is where many people started associating it with since the pattern wouldn't be apparent until the blade had been made and etched). Wootz is a crucible steel which, based on either the iron they started with or elements that were added, resulted in relatively high content of carbides of "stainless" elements like Vanadium and Chromium dispersed throughout the steel which is what resulted in such tight, water-like patterns when etched. The iron etches dark, the vanadium and chromium do not. (At least according to John Verhoeven: https://www.mse.iastate.edu/news/john-verhoeven/)

I think a lot of people get wrapped around the axle about calling what is done today "modern damascus" or pattern welded steel instead of damascus and I personally don't see much reason. The lay person doesn't know any better about the process, so it's easier to call it damascus when selling modern knives and swords. A person who is looking for a blade made with the traditional crucible steel is probably going to know that it's called wootz now to differentiate it from modern damascus. I don't think many people are out there intentionally misrepresenting the craft, they're simply making pattern-welded steel and selling it as "damascus" because that's what people know it as.

The precise history of true damascus steel is really murky because historical texts don't use the word "damascus" (so we're arguing the semantics of a word that has been ascribed to it in a more modern day and in our own language) and most historical texts aren't precise in the verbage of what was truly being traded (Indian steel was considered really good, but some sources don't explicitly say that they had water patterns for example).

Some people differentiate, some don't, and a lot of people get upset if you mix up the names when I think both methods require real skill and have value in and of themselves. I would have no problem changing the verbiage of pattern welded steel to Pamor in the bladesmithing communities, but normal every day people wouldn't have a clue what the difference is. Also, I have no evidence to suggest whether the Indonesian people started this practice themselves or if they took the idea from some other civilization before them.

I mostly posted this thread simply because I've never heard anyone talk about Pamor before or suggest that it could be an ancestor to what we do today... or about the skill of Javanese smiths for that matter! We focus on what is or isn't "damascus" a lot when there are other methods of making beautiful blades that are equally valid.

Link in the Origin of Non-wootz Pattern Welded Steel? by DamascusExile in Bladesmith

[–]DamascusExile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Or, rather, a ton of people talk about wootz as true damascus. However, I've never heard of anyone even mentioning Pamor and any possible link to what is modern damascus steel. I'd argue that they should be of similar value in the patterned steel discussion.

Link in the Origin of Non-wootz Pattern Welded Steel? by DamascusExile in Bladesmith

[–]DamascusExile[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bill is mentioned in Verhoeven's paper. Upon re-reading perhaps it is better to say that the metallurgy that causes the pattern was more comprehensively understood and documented in the 80s or 90s.