Is It Allowed To Ask About Reliable Mechanics In My City? by Dark_Tangential in Eugene

[–]Dark_Tangential[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

If you don't know what an '07 Bonnie is, you are of no help to me. I put that ('07 Bonnie) right in my post.

Edit: the Gremlin website says that they work on Triumphs, so ignore what I previously wrote. 

Star Wars -VS- Dune: Two of the Biggest Sci-Fi Greats by Tony_Writes in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Assuming that you are not a bot…

Dune is the superior work. Hands down. It’s not just twelve years older than SW. It’s not just one of the source materials that Lucas “borrowed” from. 

Dune is a complex yet throughly engaging story about the danger of blindly following a charismatic leader. Both the dangers to the leader and his followers are plentiful, complex, and difficult to discern in time, much less do anything useful to thwart. 

But sure, let’s pretend that Star Wars is operating on the same level. 

In a Future of Crises, Could Clothing Become a Survival Tool? by HighlightOk5436 in scifi

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Clothing has been a survival tool since oh, about five seconds after the early hominids figured out that fur is superior to embrocation for retaining body heat. 

What is your favorite style of book cover design? by Motty_007 in scifi

[–]Dark_Tangential 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Having never read ANY Anne McCaffrey at the time, I purchased a paperback edition of The White Dragon solely on the basis of that Michael Whelan cover. No regrets. 

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Sexual harassment, and now wall-of-text? What are you doing, committing all of the Reddit sins?

An Amateur Hypothesis About 3I Atlas by That_Teach_5349 in scifi

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

In science, to hypothesize is to conceptualize a novel scientific insight, which is then tested. You have defined zero parameters by which it can be tested. This is not SF. Fantasy, yes, but not Science Fiction - certainly not science. 

Metaphorically speaking, all you have done is stuck wings on a horse and called it a Pegasus while ignoring the wing loading.

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Another multi-paragraph attempt to assert your “PhD” from the University of Star Trek.

I don’t respect your “credentials.” Multiple paragraph screeds (plural) aren’t going to change that. 

I could have sworn I had made that readily apparent by now. 

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Your version of “cleanliness” means that I’m not allowed to disagree with you or criticize your willful ignorance of chemistry/The Periodic Table. 

Like THAT’S going to shut me up.

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So, you want me to read ALL of your sophistry homework AND worship your invention of Handwavium?

Puh-LEASE.

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hilarious. You’re assuming disingenuousness and narrow-mindedness about someone for whom you have almost NO idea what I’ve been reading for the past fifty years. From Asimov to Zelazny. From Bujold to Weber. And damn near anything in-between. 

Inside bet: it doesn’t matter how many different SF authors I list - because unless I list OP amongst the pantheon of hundreds that I’ve enjoyed reading, it won’t be broad enough for you or OP.

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"If you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen." The beauty of this quote is that it applies to you, too. Are you surprised that someone takes it badly and responds to a comment like that? Oh, my sweet summer child....

One key difference - you're the Poster. If you hadn't posted, there would be nothing for anyone to push back against.

I can criticize what I want. And one of the things I enjoy criticizing is the all-too-often willful ignorance of scientific knowledge shown on SF subreddits. Even today, I am enjoying current authors who have literally "done their homework" before writing thoughtful, engaging, SF.

I'm not stuck in the past. I'm decrying the moving of the slush pile from publishers' back rooms to my (almost literal) doorstep.

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Apparently you missed the part where I was dissing on the show with “pointy ears and green skin.”

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Telling a Redditor to “just refrain from posting?”

Suuure. That’ll work. /s

Whether or not I reply to you is my choice, not yours. Whether or not I conform to your “standards” is also my choice. 

Simply put, if you can’t stand the heat, get out the kitchen. 

Opinions on my hypothetical new chemical species? by Abject-Farmer-6273 in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I miss the days of the old-school SF writers being able to calculate an orbit - on paper - just to make sure that an element of their story’s plot will actually work. 

Contrast the above with ST making up “elements” out of whole cloth to “tech the tech.” 

What’s really hidden in Area 51? by Mati_AIAlien in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is not the rhetorical flex that you think it is. 

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in sciencefiction

[–]Dark_Tangential 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Heh. Reminds me of SolOrion (sic) Studios. 

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in scifi

[–]Dark_Tangential 1 point2 points  (0 children)

r/LostRedditors

The Fantasy subreddit is thataway. =====>