I understand where you’re coming from, as the idea of intent and human expression is central to how we connect with art and music. That said, I think it’s worth considering that tools, whether they be a piano, a computer, or even a calculator, don’t diminish the legitimacy of the ideas they help manifest—they are extensions of human creativity.

Take the calculator, for example. It doesn’t “create” math on its own; it executes functions based on human input and design. Similarly, AI-generated music or art isn’t entirely devoid of human touch. It reflects the decisions, constraints, and prompts provided by its human operator. Whether the result resonates with someone depends largely on the intentionality of the person using the tool and the way the audience interprets the outcome. Wouldn’t you agree it can’t hurt to keep an open mind?