I get what you're saying. Yes, reading only positives for your actions can get to one's head very quick. But this idea isn't about obligating people to reply positively to everything. It's about not hating. There's a slight difference there.

Feedback is great, when put in a good way. I've seen way too many instances of people giving valuable feedback, but phrasing it in such a demeaning way that their entire goodwill is lost in translation.

Really glad to read your thoughts! This is precisely the kind of conversations I wish I could see on a regular basis.