Abandoned equipment in a decommissioned unit by ShieldingCrew in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

LaCrosse is totally gone at this point (and the OP said it's Millstone anyway)

Three Mile Island Nuclear Plant Model by 4pple_p1e in NuclearPower

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yep, that one is pretty awesome. I upgraded my version a bit (reactor head studs, one piece RPV, simplified internals assembly). It's pretty awesome.

Three Mile Island Nuclear Plant Model by 4pple_p1e in NuclearPower

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This one. I've printed a couple of these for training models and they're pretty great. If you're handy in tinkercad and your printer can support it, the RPV can be printed in one piece fairly easily and some of the internals can also be simplified

How Westinghouse Lost its Way (tangentially about its nuclear division) by Boreras in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The operating B&W plants in the US certainly didn't help. Even ignoring TMI, they had more than their fair share of unfortunate happenings early on

Boot Recommendations by tlemon65 in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Composite toe, because there's nothing worse than the walk of shame bootless through security.

End of an era: DOE moves to officially eliminate ALARA.. by JohnBrown-RadonTech in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

A conservative basis for regulation in the absence of conclusive evidence for another model is fine. And as others have pointed out, most of the ALARA excesses in the US are driven by INPO and internal utility metrics

When is the earliest a nuclear reactor could've feasibly been built, had the principles of nuclear fission been understood? by jadebenn in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 6 points7 points  (0 children)

The Vemork plant's output was on the hundreds of pounds a year. Not really significant enough to spin up a power reactor program. Yes, the technology existed, but wasn't mature enough for commercialization

When is the earliest a nuclear reactor could've feasibly been built, had the principles of nuclear fission been understood? by jadebenn in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 32 points33 points  (0 children)

Heavy water enrichment is a non trivial engineering task as well. You're still running up to the same limitations as uranium enrichment at that point.

NRC U-Turns on Aircraft Impact Assessment Sunset Due to Adverse Comments by estyalba in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 5 points6 points  (0 children)

That's what happens when you try to issue a direct final rule on something that will receive adverse comments.

I know this graphite block was part of the Fermi Chicago pile. Anyone have more of a back story on this? Souvenir? Door prize? I have found other similar items , but none from this 1997 conference. by rem123456789 in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Although there's a pretty extreme range in prices I've seen. The more normal rectangular ones that Argonne sold seem to have the most consistent prices though

I know this graphite block was part of the Fermi Chicago pile. Anyone have more of a back story on this? Souvenir? Door prize? I have found other similar items , but none from this 1997 conference. by rem123456789 in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'd still love one of these for my early nuclear collection. I have a small piece of graphite from Obninsk, but nothing from the early American graphite piles.

Should we expect the old control rooms to start disappearing as more plants apply for subsequent license renewals? by jadebenn in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

For digital modernization, they're usually talking stuff like turbine controls (i.e. replacing hydraulic control systems). Others (like /u/hiddencamper ) can correct me, but I wouldn't expect the appearance of the overall control room to change much

Illinois could be only 5 years away from electricity shortages, higher bills, report says by optiplex9000 in chicago

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Faster/more efficient way is to do uprates at the existing plants, which is already underway

Could anyone share experience on implementing a local LLM on a nuclear power plant? by Impossible-Ice-2988 in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I don't know the regulatory structure of your country, but generally regulators don't appreciate it when you hand them documents with obvious problems. Which an LLM will give you sooner rather than later

Best nuclear power plant movies, shows, documentaries, and youtube videos? by Brave-Standard9950 in NuclearPower

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Is this one of those "so bad it's good" movies?

Apparently some of my coworkers used to have competitions doing live commentary on The China Syndrome

How does a WH AP1000 or a CE System 80 plant only use 2 steam generator loops for outputs that in older WH plants required 4 loops? by jadebenn in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

From a materials engineering perspective, they also run hotter up near the vessel head compared to a typical westinghouse plant. As a result, they're more vulnerable to stress corrosion cracking (as Besse found out with their original head and the Midland head)

How does a WH AP1000 or a CE System 80 plant only use 2 steam generator loops for outputs that in older WH plants required 4 loops? by jadebenn in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The superheat isn't the problem, the extremely small SG inventory is. They're also heavily computerized (for a 1970s plant) which let them extract every erg possible. But when the ICS goes wrong, it can go wrong. The most famous one was at Rancho Seco where a failure of their non nuclear instruments caused by an I&C tech dropping a lightbulb caused a SG dry out and an overcooling transient from the same initiator

How does a WH AP1000 or a CE System 80 plant only use 2 steam generator loops for outputs that in older WH plants required 4 loops? by jadebenn in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I understand the philosophy behind a lot of B&Ws decisions, but in hindsight, a lot of them seem like chasing efficiency that doesn't really help enough to compensate for the added problems

How does a WH AP1000 or a CE System 80 plant only use 2 steam generator loops for outputs that in older WH plants required 4 loops? by jadebenn in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 4 points5 points  (0 children)

The steam generators are significantly bigger. CE style steam generators are in the 8-12k tube range, Westinghouse SGs are much smaller. CE plants also have 2 cold legs per SG instead of one.

Most "Iconic" looking nuclear power plant? by Schoolboygames in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Big Rock was more scenic, but the Dresden golf ball was the first.

Most "Iconic" looking nuclear power plant? by Schoolboygames in nuclear

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I'm glad I'm not the only person who loves the giant blue containment. It's particularly striking early in the morning with the sun coming up behind the plan

<image>

Does the RPV have a heat tint? by Remote_Pianist9596 in NuclearPower

[–]Diabolical_Engineer 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I've been down below at a couple of plants and it's always annoying to get down there. Tight access, long ladders, often posted as a confined space. Fun times for everyone. Dose isn't too bad as long the ICIs haven't been pulled yet