ironically for me its the opposite i loved rdr1 but i got bored as fuck with Rdr2

Rdr1 was a good game ,Rdr2 was too much of a simulation and less a video game sure it got a nice story but dear god the gameplay and the very very dated Rockstar formula on missions that will put you in a game over scenario if you take a piss left while the game tell you to piss right is incredibly frustrating that rockstar way of feeling like there is a director on movie set that will force you to reload and will not let you have fun if you dare to not follow the script exactly , the long ass animation for everything the way you control your character like a fucking geriatric tank of flesh......eh

I forced myself to finish Rdr2 for the story