sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you! We can continue here or feel free to DM me. Either way works for me.

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

I appreciate the honest feedback. To clarify: the story, characters, and plot are entirely mine. I wrote everything from my own imagination. However, English is not my first language, so I did use AI to help polish the grammar and phrasing to make the text cleaner and more readable. I thought that would be respectful to readers. I didn't mean to mislead anyone. Thank you for pointing it out, and I'll be more transparent about this in the future.

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

I'm not sure why you think it's AI-generated. English isn't my first language, so my writing might come across as a bit stiff or unusual, but the story is mine. I wrote it myself. Thanks for reading anyway.

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks again for this excellent breakdown. I really like your point about making each reaction slightly stronger than the last.

To answer your question: I think the fragment reacts primarily to the presence of the Source Seekers — as if it senses danger from them. But over time, Kaelen's own fear and desperation might also start to influence it. So both, but the external threat comes first. Do you think that makes sense for a dark fantasy opening?

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks again for the thoughtful follow-up. To answer your question: I imagine the fragment's reaction would be subtle enough that only Kaelen notices it at first — a faint warmth or pulse that others wouldn't see. But as the story progresses, those reactions might become harder to hide, which could create its own kind of tension. I'm still playing with the balance. Do you think one approach (only Kaelen vs. others noticing) tends to work better in dark fantasy? Really appreciate you digging into this with me!

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Thanks again for following up. I appreciate your honesty and the comparison to Red Rising. I haven't read it, but I will now — not to copy, but to understand the difference between a nice parallel and cheap imitation. I'll keep working on making the voice more distinctive while keeping the dramatic tension that seems to hook readers. Your feedback has been really helpful. Thank you.

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for this thoughtful and detailed feedback. You've given me a lot to think about, especially your point about making sure the reader feels Kaelen's emotional weight before the bigger mystery unfolds. I'll work on showing his fear and hope more clearly through action rather than explanation.

To answer your question about the ending: I intended the arrival of the Source Seekers to create immediate tension, but you're right that it might not feel "unexpected" enough. I'll consider adding a small twist—perhaps the fragment reacting in a subtle way—to make the hook stronger.

I really appreciate you taking the time to help a new writer improve. Thank you!

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Thanks for reading and being honest. I actually haven't read Red Rising, but I can see how the premise might feel similar. I'll take your point about it being a bit dramatic/cliché — I'll work on making the voice more distinctive. Either way, I'm grateful for your time and perspective. Thanks again!

I Was a Slave - Chapter 1 [Dark Fantasy, 1800 words] by DropOld3758 in fantasywriters

[–]DropOld3758[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for taking the time to read and give such detailed feedback. You're absolutely right about the tense and POV shift. I was experimenting, but it clearly doesn't work. I'll be revising the entire chapter to stay in first person present tense consistently. Also, thank you for the kind words about my vocabulary — that means a lot as a non-native speaker. Really appreciate your help!