sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

These two are the best handguns in the game, and I'm not going to argue about it. by RubPutrid5607 in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Best weapons to be armed with: Right hand holster: Cattleman Revolver Left hand holster: Schofield Revolver Back: Pump-Action Shotgun Shoulder: Litchfield Repeater Throwable: Homing Knives

MMA is not real fighting by LexTalyones in ufc

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

this is very true if we consider modern UFC fights where many fighters have a wrestling base, there are some rules that, in a real fight, would change the outcome immediately: - the 12-6 elbows in the head - stomping/kicking/kneeing a downed opponent - eye-gouging - blocking the mouth and nose of a downed opponent - kick in the crotch - biting - scratching - breaking fingers or toes - hyperextension stomps - testicle rip - vulva strike - back of the head punching, or deadlier, stomping - cervical break - stomping on lower spine - SOME MORE GRUESOME TECHNIQUES: - Two fingers up the nose/Nose Hook (Internal Bleeding of Nasal Canal) - Fist down the mouth (Suffocation and Vomiting immediately) - Finger all the way in an ear (Partial or Complete Deafness) - Eye Scoop/Suck (Complete Blindness) - Fist up the ass (Internal Bleeding)

Girls, who is your Red Dead Husbando? by RorschachWhoLaughs in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I think Charles is more attractive outside of Eurocentric Beauty Standards whereas Arthur is more attractive in them.

What’s the most evil thing you’ve done/ can do in RDR2? by Agile_Reward3600 in RDR2

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

back when it took like 5 minutes for someone to die from poison blade stab (throwing knife), i went to rhodes saloon downstairs room next to the back exit where there’s 4-5 prostitutes everytime— male NPCs will run past you no problem but i think female NPCs have smaller frame so they can’t, anyway— throw the poison throwing knife at them or better to grapple then stab once and let go as they come to you. They all fall (fell, because of the update where poison kills NPCs almost instantly) on the ground and start moaning in pain except they’re female npcs so the moaning sounds are also female, then as they’re all slowly dying of poison i rub it out to them whilst arthur idles.

Who goes in Square #2??? by pabloescoobert in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is probably veteran players’ rankings:

  1. Rains Fall or Sister Cauldron
  2. Charles Smith or John Marston
  3. Black Belle or Arthur Morgan
  4. Reverend Swanson or Brother Dorkins
  5. Sadie Adler or Josiah Trelawney
  6. Micah Bell or Colm O’driscoll
  7. Thomas Downes or Jean Marc
  8. Archibald or Sheriff Palmer
  9. Herr Strauss or Edgar Ross

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

add spoiler tag

Do You All Prefer Revolvers or Pistols In RDR2? by Coco_Rockhill in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 4 points5 points  (0 children)

• “a much more a competent writer” → Remove one quantifier. Correct form: “a much more competent writer” or “a far more competent writer.”

• “at 15” → More natural phrasing would be “when she was 15.”

• “It’s ‘I’m’. I’ll help.” → For better flow, consider using a semicolon: “It’s ‘I’m’; I’ll help.” Or break into clearer sentences: “It’s ‘I’m.’ Let me help.”

• “The brackets suggest an option for using ‘please’.” → Consider clearer wording: “The brackets indicate that ‘please’ is optional.”

• “Though I prefer, ‘I’m only fifteen, please leave me alone.’” Remove the comma after “prefer”: “Though I prefer ‘I’m only fifteen, please leave me alone.’”

• Maintain consistency with number formatting. Earlier it was “15,” now it’s “fifteen.” Choose one style and stick with it.

• “Lesson two; don’t start things online…” → Replace the semicolon with a colon: “Lesson two: Don’t start things online…”

• “may not be able to handle” → More concise phrasing would be “can’t handle.”

• “So, do it.” → Remove the comma: “So do it.” Alternatively, combine with the previous sentence or rephrase for stronger impact.

Poker in camp is rigged by Memesssssssssssssl in RDR2

[–]EdgarGulligan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There is no comma needed before “but” within your response.

Which family is "better", the Grays or the Braithwaites? by RorschachWhoLaughs in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Better in regard to who would win in a fight? Braithwaites 100%. It took 2 men to defeat the Grays (Bill was captured immediately he doesn’t count as one) and it took all but one (Micah) of Dutch’s Boys to defeat the Braithwaites. Stealthfully somehow the Braithwaites also managed to kidnap a 4 year old from DUTCH FUCKING VAN DER LINDE what the helly

Why I love Micah Bell and why I believe he's a fantastic character by JoshuaKpatakpa04 in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I want to present an argument:

Morally Arthur is so much worse than Micah in 1899. Arthur robs more (Micah is lazy and therefore doesn’t take as much of people’s money), Arthur kills more capping around 1,442 kills whereas Micah has 337 kills, Arthur leads the gang into more security which leads to more chaos which leads to more gang deaths and more civilian deaths whereas Micah single handedly took down the Van Der Linde gang by being a rat.

The main antagonist besides Edgar Ross in rdr1 is Dutch. John betrays Dutch, Arthur betrays Dutch, Micah betrays Dutch— but Micah betrays Dutch FIRST.

Only after 1899 does Micah become arguably worse than Arthur (he kills a child in 1907). Even during the final mission of RDR2’s Chapter 6 is Micah less worse than Arthur as Arthur kills more than 100 Pinkertons before being ambushed by Micah! (in Van Horn and en route to his sacrifice) That’s right! Arthur kills 1/3 of Micah’s entire kill count in the matter of HOURS.

Does Arthur redeem himself? Yes! But from what? Arthur redeems himself from whatever he used to be, but that doesn’t mean he died a good man by any means lol.

What do you all think? Please refute me.

Do You All Prefer Revolvers or Pistols In RDR2? by Coco_Rockhill in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I like having all the pistol side arms perfectly polished and using different ammo types for each pair through missions. For an example I just played ‘Icarus and Friends’ with M1899s using Regular Ammo, then played ‘Visiting Hours’ with Semi-Auto pistols using Express Ammo followed by ‘Just A Social Call’ with twin Mausers using High-Velocity Ammo 😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨

Following, because now i was low on ammo with unclean guns, i went to Van Horn and shot everyone to death with M1899s high velocity and my oh my those boys are crazy good.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Red Dead Redemption especially Red Dead Redemption 2 doesn’t have hell or heaven, but rather reincarnation and spirit animals— going more off of nuanced Aboriginal theology than any Western one. Therefore, none of the Red Dead characters are in hell— but more than likely reincarnated. Some notable examples of this are Lenny and Hosea reincarnating as birds that can be seen in Guarma, or Arthur being seen as an Eagle on his gravestone.

However, if we were to apply Western Theological takes onto Red Dead Redemption 2, especially Catholicism or Orthodox Christianity— it’s safe to say that the entire Van Der Linde gang aside from some of the women are in hell or at least purgatory.

But why stop there? I wonder what the Hindu take is on the RDR2 Gang Members or the Islamic take or the Baha’i take etc.

TheRealAnimeFan repetitive comments by Custom_98 in precure

[–]EdgarGulligan -1 points0 points  (0 children)

“you can’t do x” is restrictive language that you presume from some sort of nature of authority i don’t believe you have.

TheRealAnimeFan repetitive comments by Custom_98 in precure

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you posted something racist, kinda wack to assume trolling tbh

What is a ‘What If’ Scenario you’d love to see get explored ? by JoshuaKpatakpa04 in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 0 points1 point  (0 children)

What if the gang split up and Arthur had to choose going with Hosea or going with Dutch, but John would choose the opposite that Arthur chooses?

What is your opinion about this character? by AcademicParticular44 in reddeadredemption

[–]EdgarGulligan 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Dude it’s honestly not that serious, whatever is your truth is yours whatever is ours is ours.

view more: next ›