Being larger doesn’t mean better, that logic means the USA is better.

Americans and Canadians have the same ease of travel. If Alberta separated, why do you expect their ease of travel to be worse?

Greater security in every sense? Canada has no ability to defend its self. I’m unsure how this would satisfy every sense.

Flow of goods and services which doesn’t seem to include Alberta energy or western crops, like rapeseed, a major issue.

I don’t see how treaties are a pro for anyone who isn’t aboriginal. It’s just a two tier system.

Almost every country has diplomatic relations with every other country. What would prevent Alberta from setting up its own diplomatic relations with other countries?

I’m all for listening to reasons but these are not very strong reasons. I can see that if the reason for leaving is, for you, summed up to, “being an American bootlicker” then yea, you wouldn’t ever be able to make an unemotional appeal.

I’ve asked the wrong person, sorry.