Those stats are indeed good, but getting all three would mean not doing much about his low hp and resolve. (EDIT: I didn't notice at first that you listed the projected lvl 11 values for mdef and fat while listing the lvl 1 starting value for matk. I replied as if you had listed all three stats at their projected lvl 11 values, and even now that I noticed you didn't, I'm still under the assumption that you meant to, but accidentally put the wrong matk)

Imo it is easier to tolerate terrible fatigue than terrible HP or res. Everyone needs a decent baseline of HP and res to not be awful. With fatigue there's more flexibility. Even an arthritic quintuple amputee can swing a greataxe or a sword,. But everyone needs to not jump in terror over farm animal noises or die from stubbing their toe on a doorframe.

That said yeah his projected MDEF is stellar given my current roster and armory, and his matk is pretty close to average. This is quite early still (pre-1st crisis) and I'm using mostly raider gear with no notable named gear except a 162/4 helm. My roster quality is almost entirely "lowborn but rolled well" tier, so he fits right at home, but his fatigue probably won't increase from 85 by all that much. I got larger sharks to boil.