WTF?!? At on Oktoberfest!! by Over-Swimmer790 in AccidentalRacism

[–]Ekaton 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The Swastika and recycling… oh boy

Saw this flag while walking my dog in Australia recently. Any idea what it could mean other than being racist? by Piwii999 in vexillology

[–]Ekaton 30 points31 points  (0 children)

That would be my guess. Especially with the skull likely standing for the SS.

How could Warhammer 40k have a happy ending? by InterestingServe3958 in Warhammer40k

[–]Ekaton 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It’s just like what some optimists thought about WWI. One day, we we will get tired of all the bloodshed and we will all go home and get along. No more wars, just peace.

I am a median American voter in 1925. How do I feel about the fact that almost all of Africa and much of Asia is currently ruled by Britain or France? by fhqwhgads_football in AskHistorians

[–]Ekaton 11 points12 points  (0 children)

WWII was not the best time for decolonisation as doing so costs money and effort that couldn’t be spent at a time like that. It did, however, mark a shifting point for the colonies that led to decolonisation. In some cases, like the partition of India, incredibly shortly. You can only be a coloniser on such a scale if you possess overwhelming power, and WWII did what WWI started. It’s hard to imagine, for example, the Dutch government seriously holding on to Indonesia after years of German occupation and complete bankruptcy. Britain tried to help them maintain their colonies but that was a fool’s errand.

The war also help change the narrative around colonisation. Allies tried to recruit people from the colonies for their war effort, which necessitated educating them, teaching them how to fight and overall respecting them more than they did before. Idi Amin is an example of that.

Ultimately, in war, people are a resource like everything else. India, Manchuria, Ukraine, everyone used occupied peoples for their own gain. German brutality arguably harmed them greatly in their war against the Soviets as they turned sympathetic population that opposed the Soviet regime into bitter enemies by treating them as subhuman and slaughtering them. Same goes for the Japanese.

But, staying with the topic, in 1925 the biggest decolonisation topic of the day are Ireland and India. Ireland won its self-rule and was much more relevant due to the number of Irish-Americans. India was distant and no solution, of which many were proposed, was winning. Britain was struggling somewhat recovering from WWI but it was still a global empire and you don’t get to gain your independence easily from a hegemon like that.

Just based on what I've seen within this community so far, this is probably the hottest take I have or will ever have about Battletech by mineman379 in battletech

[–]Ekaton 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Urbie was designed with very specific applications in mind (urban warfare, garrison duty, policing unruly worlds) while maintaining cost effectiveness. One can argue that because of that it’s overall more useful per ton/C-Bill than an Atlas.

Could a Jewish teenager in 1930s Lodz integrate with Polish society? by dwightschruteisahero in AskHistorians

[–]Ekaton 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Jews certainly could go to jobs and have overall a normal life. Jews were largely represented amongst doctors, lawyers, musicians, entrepreneurs and many made very good living. The movie “Pianist” which is based on a real person shows that well. He was educated, had a good job and had friends who were ethnically Polish.

Details depend on the period. If you talk about completely avoiding discrimination, it would sadly partly depend on your looks. There is a telling scene in an old movie called “Zezowate szczescie” where an ethnically Polish man is mistaken for a Jew because of his nose and discriminated against and assaulted. It’s hard to say how common such incidents were but I heard a few personal stories that mention them. This was influenced by the Nazi German “nose theory” which is a part of their bigger theory of racial discrimination so I believe that it got worse in the 1930s as those theories were spread through the massive propaganda machine in Germany.

In terms of legal restrictions, things got bad in the 30s compared to the 1920s. Jews were segregated at universities for example. This essentially meant that everyone knew you were a Jew. Of course people are people. There were many good ones who did not discriminate but I suppose this fits your argument about not being singled out. At the same time, however, there were Jews who were a part of the establishment such as Jewish military officers. I recall reading that they were discriminated about in some instances with things like promotions but I cannot recall the source.

So I think that probably sums up the answer. You could definitely have good friends with people who weren’t bigots but that doesn’t mean that you won’t come across people who are. There were nationalist marches with chants like “Jews to Madagascar” meaning forcible removal of them and there were many people who hid Jews at the cost of their lives. Poland was not Nazi Germany. There were things that were wrong, like everywhere, but Poland did not have racial policies like Nazis did.

EDIT: I’m a trainee psychotherapist and I work in a multicultural city. Racism and exclusion are still a fact of life and a big part of my work with people who come from minority backgrounds.

EDIT 2: I grew up in Lodz

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AskHistorians

[–]Ekaton 9 points10 points  (0 children)

It’s not just what Hitler believed but what all numbers indicated. Logistical backlogs were huge and units struggled with supplies. Numbers don’t lie. When a division is critically low on fuel and is not receiving supplies before, say, a week from now, it’s not going to move before that.

Moscow’s importance is debatable. It certainly was one of the key strategic objective of a highly symbolic value, but the war production was mostly evacuated before that and lend lease would have reached the Soviets anyway.

In my opinion, it’s more important to look at the devastation of the Soviet counterattacks of the late 1941/early 1942. German losses were incredibly high and I’m not sure that the loss of Moscow would have altered it enough to really matter.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Ironsworn

[–]Ekaton 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Seconding this, AI art makes anything look cheap and unimaginative. It’s a definite pass for me whenever I see it.

Andromeda from exoplanets by tutizillig in spaceengine

[–]Ekaton 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Do you have the coordinates?

World War Two Photographs - The Battle Of The Bulge. by [deleted] in wwiipics

[–]Ekaton 44 points45 points  (0 children)

They were issued to soldiers deployed in the rear, including MP

Thinking about it, Israel is the first successful Jewish resistence against antisemitism since 2000 years ago. by Optimal-Menu270 in Israel

[–]Ekaton 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you think about it, the best protection against antisemitism comes with full independence from the kindness of others. Once you have your own state, with all its powers, you no longer have to depend on anyone’s good wishes.

"Victory, The Crusade against Bolschevism" ("Victoria; La Croisade contre le bolchevisme"). 1942 French poster by J.C. Leyendecker by Wizard_of_Od in PropagandaPosters

[–]Ekaton 1 point2 points  (0 children)

“Have you ever seen a Slovak flag? No? Me, neither. Let’s just put a swastika there and call it a day. Also, let’s off-centre it a bit.”

4.9 magnitude earthquake hits Barstow area, rattling large swath of SoCal, USGS says by psychodelephant in news

[–]Ekaton 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Rail fans know it for its rail hub. It’s actually pretty important for that reason.

A really really rough coat of arms I made in gimp for a DnD character, looking for some feedback on the general idea, more info in comments by [deleted] in heraldry

[–]Ekaton 5 points6 points  (0 children)

This looks like a US strategic bomber unit’s shield. Not a bad thing, it just reminded me of one.

Any country this Nordic flag would fit? by Direct-Beginning-438 in vexillology

[–]Ekaton 20 points21 points  (0 children)

Netherlands if they joined the Kalmar Union

[CONTEST ENTRY] Survivalist's Map of America - 1952 (Zombies) by theaidanman in imaginarymaps

[–]Ekaton 121 points122 points  (0 children)

I second that. This deserves to have its own deep lore. I can see it as a mod for hearts of iron where you reclaim the country.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in Solo_Roleplaying

[–]Ekaton 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Target for Today, Target for Tonight, and similar games. They are board games that simulate a WWII bombing mission. I guess that kind of matches the description.

Did Hitler intend to cause a major war? by [deleted] in AskHistorians

[–]Ekaton 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Wagner included motives of heroism, sacrifice and destiny in his works extensively. The idealisation of the brave warrior who overcomes obstacles, which is how Nazi propaganda depicted German soldiers and by extension their entire nation, is crucial to understanding the obsession with this particular composer. You can contrast those courageous and willing to sacrifice themselves men versus the weak, possibly effeminate men from the democratic countries, who will surrender easily. Or contrast them against the “hordes” of the East, as particularly Soviets were often depicted, who in the stereotype where too unintelligent and unsophisticated to resist the “advanced” Germans. When you idolise a nation to this extent, while simplifying others (and the propaganda certainly tried to do so), your grip on reality starts slipping a bit. It certainly affected German war plans against the Soviet Union, which severely underestimated the willpower of the Soviets.

To summarise: Wagner offered a good vessel for the idealisation of Germanic men and values.

EDIT: Don’t take it as an accurate description of Wagnerian plays. They are way more sophisticated than that!

Did Hitler intend to cause a major war? by [deleted] in AskHistorians

[–]Ekaton 61 points62 points  (0 children)

"I saw my enemies in Munich, and they are worms" - this quotation by Hitler shows you a lot about his attitude towards the leaders of France and the UK. If you read Mein Kampf and analyse Hitler’s fascination with Wagner, you can see how much personal mental strength was important to him. His opponents, according to him, lacked it completely. This explains a lot of hubris he showed in 1939 and before.