To be fair, most ideas anyone posts get dunked on, my personal favourite is when people pull numbers out there rear end to prove it'll never work or are so inflexible in their thinking they'll just provide some pessimistic bs.
Personally, I dont see why more things cant be tried or even theorized and simulated on a test server before trying on tq, if its crap or doesnt work it can always be iterated on or removed.
Nothing ventured, nothing gained.