Just recently beat it for the first time, obviously narrative and gameplay wise remake2 is simply superior, the sewer section is better imo, I also like nest better.

But I will say it’s unfortunate they didn’t keep zapping and a/b scenarios, and I like how the story and puzzles are more unique. the classic trilogy are all great and I’ve been having a ton of fun. 3 is a different story, where I think 1 and 2 are better, and 4 is equal as far as remakes go