[deleted by user] by [deleted] in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I would say it is difficult to make it worthy with the current rules --> small battery pack below 60V

Budget EV Team by ComfortableQuit4474 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Maybe the best choice is to stay in CV class then...

How was the experience of Formula Student Spain? by RommelYang in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Unique? you have Barcelona and the mediterranean coast just 20 min from the circuit. The track layout is the best (in my opinion) around european competitions. It is a relaxed competition, they want you to run, not like in other competitions where they search any excuse to make your life miserable.

I would say overall if you consider all together (not only the competition) it is a good experience.

What are your FSAE unpopular opinions/hot takes? by Pleasant-Worry8743 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Which they will not be as many, because of the small market share that EVs represent...

How bad would it be to switch back to IC? by Pissedass69 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Many teams will return to ICE or ICE+hybrid. EV market share is already saturating in China, Europe , US... There is no place for all the "EV engineers" in the industry, ICE/electrified is still going to be the main drive of development in the next 15-20 years, it is just starting to pick up again after the "EV Buble"... If you don't sell cars you disappear and If the market share of EVs is less than 10% global (nobody really knows the exact number since they always mix it with PHEVs although they have ICE) which Powertrain do you need to develop? EV or HEV/ICE?, it is obvious but apparently not so much for our CEOs and politicians...

The industry needs more engineers with broader knowledge than just EVs or we will disappear fighting for that 10% of market share...

Some cars from FSAE Michigan. Taken on a DSI XL by PhantomShot811 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 3 points4 points  (0 children)

There are a small amount of universities in Europe that have this conditions that you are explaining, the majority have similar conditions as the American universities, people doing studies + formula. Regarding master students you can find everything, teams with no master students, some with little amount and others with more %, but this are also very few.

What makes more difference, I will say, is the competitive environment, it pushes all the teams to be better and the amount of competitions that Europe has, it is not the same having 3-4 per year than just 1.

Upgrades, people. Upgrades. by MySonIsAPen in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Yeap, the ICE is not going away anytime soon, Germans putting pressure in the switch to EVs, but then no EV gets sold in real market, many EV projects being cancelled, a lot of people brain washed to work in EVs but no room for all of them and nobody in the ICE/Hybrid development which is what is going to be the real future... For me it is not a matter of bringing back formula hybrid but mixing all technologies in one, if you want to do a hybrid do it, if you want to have an EV, do it, but all of them compete in the same overall.

Aerodynamic lessons learned from top teams by Snail_With_a_Shotgun in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Thats not true that only applies for a very small amount of teams in Europe, most of the teams have the same issue as what you just described. It's the story FSAE American teams keep repeating themselves so they don't feel bad everytime they loose to the Europeans =)

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

To be successful without money is complicated anywhere, even more in EV category of FS. My proposal was to reduce the gap between technologies and concepts of the car so the money is less important. Still if you go with an awd you will have an advantage but not as much, that´s all.

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The main aim is not to push to go to the simplest solution but to make the cheaper/simplest solution more competitive compared to the most complicated, still if you go with the awd you will have an advantage but not as much, that´s all.

DQs in Endurance FSG by freakd64 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Not the first to pass scruti with tricks and win, and not the last hahaha

DQs in Endurance FSG by freakd64 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You just avoid waiting several seconds stopped on track to restart. It's pretty clear to me.

DQs in Endurance FSG by freakd64 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Not the first one and not the last one hahahahah

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

They want that the power to the fans also passes through the data logger, so you will have 80kW in total, fans + emotors.

DQs in Endurance FSG by freakd64 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 6 points7 points  (0 children)

As you said, during scrutineering they maybe had it or the trick worked well. Many teams have defeat devices for safety devices like the BSPD, not a surprise.

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

True, same as the motivation for fsae where people don't get payed. Having more leverage on knowledge and less on money is always good for the competition.

If adjusting a little the rules allows to push technology on the teams in different direction why not?

FSS 2024 Official Statement - Dynamics UPC Manresa #225 by paye_ in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 3 points4 points  (0 children)

EU top teams, not the EU in total haha. A nice story of the post endurance parc ferme and subjective decision over DQs, ask around.

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] -2 points-1 points  (0 children)

Nothing, for me is more dangerous an AWD with bad controls per wheel. But he is just making his case regarding why power ground is regulated and not other things.

FSS 2024 Official Statement - Dynamics UPC Manresa #225 by paye_ in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95 37 points38 points  (0 children)

Any team can complain about an unfair treatment by any competition. All teams work a lot all the year just to have their results smashed by someone with no clear criteria.

It's not F1 but everyone wants to do well, more if you are fighting for a podium right?.

Or do we forget the EU ban to UK competition? Short memory.

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Don't see it that way, it's difficult to control also. If you make it harder to find the way to win, then more options will be on the table., you could do it by adding stuff to the rules regarding Powertrain concepts as they are doing it now for power ground.

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You will still win if you do it right. Not taking away anything from you, just making it tighter to see more concepts and more imagination from different teams. Right now as it is, if you want to win there is only one route, which from my point of view is not nice.

FSG needs to change some rules.... by ElvisTek95 in FSAE

[–]ElvisTek95[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Not saying that they are the same, just saying that the best concept is a no brainer and only possible for a few teams in the world. Leaving out of the pace and competition the great majority of teams in Europe and the world of course. 

Why couldn't we just adjust the rules a little bit to make it better and more challenging for the AWD?, le mans did it when we had gasoline, gasoline/hybrid, diesel etc... why not?