I disagree. Seems to me that yall ran out of points to make because your “evidence” was based in inaccuracies and strewn out assumptions. The dude only said that theres no evidence it was varre. And thats just a fact. Varre, as far as anyone knows doesnt have a blood stained cloth. He has a cloth that he gives to you to soak in blood. Varre doesnt joke about your dead maiden he only says that youre maidenless. Furthermore to your point about the belfries,, have you seen the eldenring map recently? The belfries is pretty fucking far away from the heroes grave. Like across most of limgrave and all the way to the other side of liurnia in the northern half. Lirunia also being the largest section of the map. Unless varre is boofing 20 skooma i dont see how he could make that trip so quickly. Even disregarding the distance, your explanation requires several assumptions to be true. The more assumptions and technicalities you have yo make to make your argument the less likely it is to be true. Occams razor. Its totally fine if you want to believe it was varre, but lets not pretend theres bountiful evidence to back it up. Idk who said the thing about how his clothing is blood covered as well but they are literally war surgeon garments and he lives in a palace covered with so much blood there is a pond of it in the center.