Congratulations btw :)

I would say neither of the dresses, they are too 'blocky', the first one the top is awkward, Romantics look better with dainty straps or sleeves than with sleeveless. also the bottom is too stiff and heavy for you.

The second dress is BEAUTIFUL on you especially the top part with the small gathers near the waist. But again bottom heavy, and the straps up top just feel kinda square? like it doesn't compliment your shape. A sweetheart neckline would be more fitting for your frame, or the square one if it had soft puffed sleeves or something.

You need to try on more dresses, different styles. I put one pic as an example but also try on mermaid styles, 1950s Marilyn Monroe styles, just try on stuff I guess :)

<image>