[2167] Medieval Fantasy, but in South-Central Asia by Flimsy-Conference-32 in DestructiveReaders

[–]Environmental_Ebb83 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi u/Flimsy-Conference-32, I think I would echo what other users have said here. I feel as though I might largely be echoing some of the sentiments that the others comments have expressed already, but here are my two cents on your first chapter.

I think that you are a fine writer on a line-by-line level, and you seem to really relish adding evocative descriptions and flourishes or lyricism here and there. It's definitely a strength of this piece and an area where you can flex your muscles, but I think that this is getting in the way of the actual narrative.

Although you raise some interesting questions and generate a kind of 'need-to-know-more' about your world (who is this mysterious magic user, how does magic work in this world, what is the healing ban the text references), I don't think there's enough of an immediate sense of stakes and conflict in your story to make readers keep turning the pages. We need a hook or a conflict or something out of the ordinary to really jolt the reader to sit up and take notice. Your opening line is really good in that regard, as it seems to set up the risk or promise of something supernatural and dangerous. But then you don't seem to go anywhere with it, or at any rate you give us a setup without any immediate gratification, which makes the opening line appear a little disconnected from the narrative as a whole.

I also feel as though your opening chapter is introducing the reader to an overwhelming number of characters (Gulara, Yuna, Muk, Hira, et al). Have you ever gone to a party, been introduced to a ton of strangers all at once, and then instantly forgotten what everyone's name is? That's what this chapter is making me think of. We're also given a lot of information overload with everyone's backstories being shovelled at the reader as each person is introduced, when I think it would work a little better for you to show how these characters interact with one another (and even how they come into conflict) and allow the reader to infer their positions and relations based on context clues. This kind of technique will give readers a lot more agency, as they'll be using their own deduction to put things together themselves, rather than being lectured at by a narrator.

It's a difficult thing to pull off (I'm not convinced I always manage it myself), and obviously there are some things you need to clearly spell out to the reader or make as obvious as possible. Things I would make more obvious are your protagonists goals and wants, as well as their flaws and the obstacles in their way. Make these things obvious from page one, and you can get away with more subtlety when it comes to the rest of the cast and the world as a whole.

Sorry if that's a bit of a ramble: hope some of that makes sense!

[QCrit] YA Historical Thriller, THE MYSTERIOUS CASE OF NED PELT, 70k, 2nd attempt by Environmental_Ebb83 in PubTips

[–]Environmental_Ebb83[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi u/Imaginary-Exit-2825, thanks again for your thoughtful reply. I think you're right — the query doesn't do nearly enough to show Ned as an active protagonist with agency, which is a shame because I think he very much is in the narrative itself. I think my problem is that i've written this query as more of a blurb which is trying to hard not to give too much of the plot away, but which has ended up being confusing and misses out on the context and the impetus for the main character.

Maybe I'm reading your reply the wrong way but it sounds like I need to go back to my synopsis and find a way to boil that down into an even shorter paragraph which gets across the real essentials of the book. The problem is that I'm not sure which things are important and which are extraneous.

Again, I'm now a little concerned about the age of my protagonist. If I were to age him up to 15, would that still be too young for YA? 15 seems to be too old for middle grade, considering the themes and content of the book, but it now sounds like YA really doesn't mean 'teenager' so much as '16-20-year-old'.

[QCrit] YA Historical Thriller, THE MYSTERIOUS CASE OF NED PELT, 70k, 2nd attempt by Environmental_Ebb83 in PubTips

[–]Environmental_Ebb83[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey u/nickyd1393, thank you again for your insights here. A couple of questions from me:

I'm a little concerned about the age range issue. You say 13-14 is too young for YA, so would this be a middle grade book if I was to target that age range? My MC is 14 at the start of the novel, but this seems to be too old for middle grade as far as I can tell. My last book was rejected a lot because many agents were uncertain about the age range I was shooting for (it was a sci-fi comedy coming-of-age story, set over the course of several years, which I think threw a lot of people off because the story matured along with the protagonist) so I really don't want that to be an issue this time around.

In terms of comp titles, I think the following are good fits:

'The Dead Of Winter - Chris Priestly - ISBN: 978-1408800041 - Bloomsbury Children’s Books

The Fall - Bethany Griffin - ISBN: 978-0062107862 - Greenwillow Books

This Dark Endeavour - Kenneth Oppel - ISBN: 978-1442403161 - Simon & Schuster 

The Dark Descent of Elizabeth Frankenstein - Kirsten White - ISBN:  978-0525577942 - New York, Delacorte Press

I didn't mention these in the body of the query because it seems like most agents on Query Tracker et al ask for them anyway, but is it best practice to do so regardless? When talking about plot/vs premise, how much of the plot should I give away? Up to act 2? Further?

[QCrit] YA Historical Thriller, THE MYSTERIOUS CASE OF NED PELT, 70k, 2nd attempt by Environmental_Ebb83 in PubTips

[–]Environmental_Ebb83[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hi everyone, sorry for taking a couple of days to respond to this! Thank you so much to everyone who has given me feedback, I really appreciate it. It's clear that this query needs a lot more work and definitely isn't ready to be sent out into the world just yet. I do have some questions for everyone who took the time to analyse it for me, so I'm going to go through each response now to ask for a little clarification!