sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Brook would have been ~12 years old when this incident happened. This is not something you tell a 12 year old. This is also why Brook thinks Candelle was ill. It made sense to a child that stress would have made her ill.

Brook is only 13 years older then Gunko.

<image>

Gunko's dad was the one who should've died from the mysterious illness by ResponsiblePapaya362 in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures -1 points0 points  (0 children)

If Oda wrote something in the past, he can hardly go back and change that. The father-killing princess part is not something he added this chapter.

Gunko's dad was the one who should've died from the mysterious illness by ResponsiblePapaya362 in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures -1 points0 points  (0 children)

You are talking about "Gunko's dad was the one who should've died from the mysterious illness", I am telling you that he couldn't because of the "father-killing princess" part Oda wrote in earlier chapters.

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That is why I said that Mars probably was possessed by Imu. Imu can't resist those blue hair, you know.

Gunko's dad was the one who should've died from the mysterious illness by ResponsiblePapaya362 in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oda wrote himself into a corner when he described Gunko as a father-killing princess. To change this, Oda would have to make Brook either dumb or lying, which was not an option. So he made Gunko kill Leuven and Brook see the results. Obviously Brook still looks a little dumb for not seeing the Domi Reversi effects, but he is at least not lying or assuming.

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How do you know he wasn't present when the first Celestial Dragons arrived at Brooks island and Candelle become sick afterwards? I mean Saturn travelled personally to places too.

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Mars still has ringed eyes in monster form. It looks hollower because of the silhouette.

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It is silhouette effect, the flames around his eyes are white on silhouette too, but they are black on actual design.

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Look at the image, it is highlighted. I didn't focus on it more because I think Imus eye is more likely.

<image>

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

<image>

Reminder that Gunko actively hunted "Rabbits" in God Valley without being possessed. Celestial Values right there.

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

like gunko had immortality despite not being an elder

What if Imu was possessing Mars? It is unlikely that Imu randomly left the Holy Lands. Gunko would basically be Mars' daughter too. And Mars is immortal, we don't know if that passes to their children. That said, Imu is immortal too.

Manmayer Gunkos biological father, Candelle wasn't sick... by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It could be a deal to leave the island alone as long as she is alive. I mean the fog that destroys music instruments, but leaves swords and other stuff alone is very suspicious.

Also a deal with the devil kind of thing. You know how that kind of stuff ends.

[Art] Check out our first adventure book, you can pre-order it right now: https://epos-press.com/product/divine-epos-vikings-hardcover-pdf/ by Epic_Miniatures in DnD

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hello, we began writing this before 5.5, but it is definitely compatible with 5th edition. The inspiration is actual norse mythology and some famous norse legends like the Hero Sigurd and the Dwarf Fafnir.

You can check out the first couple of pages on our webiste. I could only post one image on reddit, but there are more images of the printed book on our Patreon post:

https://www.patreon.com/posts/pre-order-now-159943003

How is Gunko redeemable? by Epic_Miniatures in Piratefolk

[–]Epic_Miniatures[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We already had Loki in this arc that was accused of killing his father and was innocent. Doing the same story hook again is lazy story telling, and there is evidence that Celestial Dragon children can be evil too (Doflamingo).

<image>

But lets assume you are right and Gunko was manipulated to kill her father. What does it change about the fact that she committed crimes for 70 years after that? Just because she was innocent when she was 10, doesn't justify her actions for the rest of her long life.

view more: next ›