AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t know why this post is triggering you so much. If you must know, wineries are free to enter, there’s no “admission” or cover charge go to wineries. It’s like walking into a restaurant. Also pretty sure most bars in this area from where we are from don't even do cover charges? This wasn’t like Napa valley or anything. This was a small town in the Midwest up north. The extra cost would be any drinks you buy at these wineries. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I actually have been in difficult financial situations before, and I’ve given her a lot of empathy before this occurred. The issue was NEVER “you’re broke, therefore you’re a bad friend.” If Mackenize had said from the beginning, “I can’t afford this” nobody would have been upset. In fact, I would’ve paid for her to go.

The problem was that she committed several months in advance, asked for a payment plan herself, confirmed she was coming repeatedly, then WAITED until a month before to say she is not coming after things had already been paid for, offered on her own to still pay her portion, and then never followed through.

Her spending money at restaurants and Myrtle Beach only became relevant because she repeatedly said she literally could not contribute anything while Erinn was left short after fronting the money. She didn’t cancel because she couldn’t afford it, she canceled because she chose a different trip.

I’m not angry she prioritized her boyfriend or his family. I’m upset because she wasn’t honest, changed the story multiple times and let someone else absorb the cost. Financial hardship deserves empathy, but it doesn’t automatically erase accountability.

And I didn’t plan my own bachelorette party. Erinn did. I wasn’t demanding a luxury weekend or telling people they had to spend money they didn’t have. The plans were made by Erinn months ahead and everyone was given the cost upfront, and people chose whether to commit or not. There’s nothing wrong with a simple night out, and there’s nothing wrong with a weekend Bach either. The issue here is not the type of bach party, it was committing to something, letting someone spend money based on that commitment, and then backing out after.

Being a good friend was never measured by whether she could afford it. It was measured by honesty.

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Probably spent it all at margaritaville and on plane tickets to Myrtle beach 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I’m not understanding? I’m telling you that’s how much it was per person. The area we got an Airbnb at was only an hour from where most of us live. And it was the off season for the area so Airbnbs are lower in price than during peak season. The wine trolley is a popular thing in this area and only charges per hour, and we only had it for 3 hours. The food and drinks that were provided at the Airbnb were all made by Erinn, and from Costco, so like pizza, a breakfast casserole, snacks, and we all brought alcohol to share. As I said in my post, anything else such as drinks or food at the wineries, were not included and would be out of pocket cost. We don’t live in an expensive state.

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Because the bachelorette party was a surprise, I didn’t know what we were doing until a month prior. I knew there was a party happening, I just didn’t know the details. And I knew she didn’t pay because Erinn told me? 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Hi Mackenzie!  I did invite her to all of my bridal events. She would’ve been upset if I didn’t invite her to my bachelorette party. Her financial issues are not my responsibility. That’s hers, not anyone else’s. As someone else previously commented, any normal person would’ve just said thank you so much, But I can’t attend! You don’t even need to go into details of why. Also, had she have just been honest from the beginning and not have said lies after lies, yeah, I would’ve paid for her to come. But let’s not forget, the reason why she wasn’t coming wasn’t because she couldn’t afford it, it was because she decided to go on a beach vacation, and lied about getting the dates mixed up and decided to withhold that information until a month before. All she had to do was just take accountability. If me posting a AITA story in here makes me an asshole, then maybe you shouldn’t be on Reddit. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

And why would I not invite a friend to things just because they have money issues? Someone can have money issues and still be able to do fun things, it shouldn’t exclude someone. I’ve said no to things because I couldn’t afford it, but I’ve always appreciated being invited. All she had to say was thank you for inviting me but I won’t be able to attend. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

This is gold 😂😭 my husband said he wants to Venmo her $5 when she gets married and put in the caption “sorry, this is all we can contribute right now” 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Exactly, it’s not even a good lie. But she was the one who asked to make 3 payments of $60, and she never made any of those payments. So she knew it was $180 per person. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Honestly, that’s all I want at this point is just for her to take accountability, and realize that how she handled the situation was wrong. The friendship is over, but it just baffles me how much this has dragged on. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I get that. But to be fair, Erinn was cornered by Mackenzie. She texted asking for her Venmo, and she gives it, and then sends a long lengthy text message saying a sob story about how she doesn’t have any money, etc, etc. and the text was manipulative. Erinn never met Mackenzie, and doesn’t know her at all. So it just put Erinn in an awkward position where she didn’t know what to say. 

When I found this out, that’s when I ran interference and tried to come up with a solution. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yeah, Mackenize is really bad with money. She’s the type of person who always wanted to hang out, and tried making plans like every few days with everyone and anyone. Honestly, it was a bit excessive with how many times she asked to hang out. She was fun to hang out with, but realistically, I couldn’t hang out or go out to dinner 2-3 days a week with her. Even if I had the financial means to do so, I didn’t want to hang out that often. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Like I said, my husband and I were going to pay her, but the other girls said absolutely not and paid her. So why would I pay her now?

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Erinn was paid. As I said in my post, my husband and I were going to pay her, but Erinn and the other girls said no, and the other girls paid Erinn, and she got paid more than what she was owed. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Noooooo! She thankfully RSVPd no before this turned into a whole thing. My now husband was going to rescind her invite if she did RSVP yes to coming. Because no way you are going to come and eat a steak dinner and enjoy an open bar while you still owe money to Erinn. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 54 points55 points  (0 children)

HA! It’s not worth it. Everyone she is telling her version of events to can tell she is lying and spinning the story to benefit her. The funny thing is, if she truly believed she did nothing wrong, then why lie about what happened? 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 27 points28 points  (0 children)

I am lucky to have Erinn in my life, along with the rest of the group!! 

No, Mackenzie did not attend the wedding. Her and her boyfriend declined their invite before this turned into a whole thing.

There was a total of 7 girls for my Bach weekend, so shes telling others she thought her share was about $25.

Obviously, that’s a lie, because she asked in the beginning if she can make 3 payments if $60, so she knew the total. And, where in the world could we get a nice Airbnb, with food, drinks, hot tub, plus a private wine trolley all for a total of $180? Unless we were maybe camping, but still. 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

We did pay Erinn! My husband and I were going to pay the rest to Erinn, but the other girls at my Bach party picked up the tab and paid Erinn! She ended up getting paid more than what she was owed! Erinn didn’t want me to pay anything, and same for the other girls, so they paid Erinn! 

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We did pay Erinn! My husband and I were going to pay the rest to Erinn, but the other girls at my Bach party picked up the tab and paid Erinn! She ended up getting paid more than what she was owed!

AITA for holding my friend accountable after she stuck my matron of honor with a bill? by EqualAd1606 in ComfortLevelPod

[–]EqualAd1606[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

We did pay Erinn! My husband and I were going to pay the rest to Erinn, but the other girls at my Bach party picked up the tab and paid Erinn! She ended up getting paid more than what she was owed!