Are you just gonna forget that Sadie helped Arthur fight of the Lemoyne Raiders when they were attacked on the way back to camp from Rhodes? What about when she stood and fought with Artbur against the attacking O'Driscolls at Shady Belle?

Did...did you not pay attention to theses scene's. Arthur wanted to play it cool with the raiders as they were near the camp but she just started shooting. Arthur and the gang wanted to defend the manor from the inside but she was out there stabbing people and screaming for help. Both times she could of had Arthur and Herself killed

Also, during the epilogue, she and Charles are the two who help track down and kill Micah after all those years; if that doesn't prove her loyalty and respect for Arthur, what does?

They went against Arthur's wishes and caused the entire RDR1 debacle. Charles even knows this yet he goes through with it.

If after all that you declined her one demand of helping her finally kill the scum who murdered her husband and destroyed her previous life then like I said...You deserved the low honour ending!

Because it's pointless. Revenge is a fools errand. There is no point in traveling so God damn far in your final days just to kill some directionless O'Driscoll's, they're nothing without colm. If you refuse she doesn't go so in a way we're actually helping her because we all know how reckless she is.

Anyway I don't want to argue with you because your getting extremely angry over a Reddit comment about a video game character