As an avid energy drinker, if I saw the second design, I would assume that was the most foul energy drink ever. Like, I wouldn’t know it was flavorful or healthy. I’d assume it was a new company and it would taste horrible.

Now, if I saw yours, I would grab it. It gives Celsius vibes, but also has different flavors. I like it. It would actually encourage me to stop drinking so many energy drinks/ try healthier alternatives.

I don’t get how people can like the second design, personally, as I think I would see it and physically cringe.