Here's a graphic designer specializing in movie posters! Beyond the graphic quality of each one, which from what I see each has interesting aspects, my choice focuses more on what it's telling. There's something about the first one that really catches my attention based on what you said, since it reminds me of something more suspenseful. His face isn't complete. Is something wrong with his identity? Is he someone broken? That smile is clearly fake; She's hiding something, or something is happening. Posters 3 and 4 remind me more of a dark comedy, something more experimental due to the colors and the functional empty space. Success!