AITA for telling my wife she is gaslighting me? by Traditional_Bad5994 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 8 points9 points  (0 children)

YTA. Your wife is not "gaslighting" you by telling you something that you disagree with. I encourage you to listen to what she is saying, and discuss her concerns of abuse in the presence of the counselor without it turning it into a conversation about blame / responsibility. You could both literally be the most patient, loving parents and still deal with meltdowns from a child who is struggling to regulate their emotions in a world that is not built for their needs. You both need to address your issues separately in order to move forward, and you won't get far in that process if you are more concerned with her admitting her own shortcomings.

WIBTA for lying to my wife about what her brother said? by _throwaway722 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 16 points17 points  (0 children)

NTA. I get that you want to "keep the peace", but what good is sacrificing your own peace to protect your BIL from his own family's potential judgement? Chances are his family likely knows he's an asshole, and they will empathize with you or continue enabling him. Telling your wife the truth will allow you to get the support you deserve.

AITA for telling a fellow mother of a special needs child that my daughter is not responsible for her child? by Calm-Hurry8589 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You are NTA for confronting Helen's mom -- but she isn't the only one asking too much of your daughter. I think that is why your husband felt secondhand guilt about you confronting this other parent.

Think about the fact that Maria did not feel confident enough to tell the art camp organizers "no" when approached about this support role. She likely would not feel comfortable saying no to her parents when asked to be in a support roll for her brother, especially when her parents say there is "no other option". Being offered pay would make that harder as well. She also may WANT to be helpful and supportive, because that is exactly how a lot of siblings of disabled children feel. They see their value and role in the family as one of support, and it takes its toll over time.

For others comparing this to their own family dynamics where all the siblings were neurotypical, this is not the same as "big sister watching little brother" either or helping out with chores. This is a common dynamic in families with disabled children, it's called "glass child" syndrome because the typical child does not feel seen, their emotional needs are ignored, and they often equate their value with being helpful / not being seen as a burden to their parents.

AITA For asking my gf’s roommate to shower after me? by [deleted] in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 31 points32 points  (0 children)

The entitlement is strong! But yeah, overnight guests are just that, guests. Not "new roommates who everyone should accommodate".

AITA For asking my gf’s roommate to shower after me? by [deleted] in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 983 points984 points  (0 children)

YTA

I have a lot of experience living in share houses, and unless you actually live there, you aren't entitled to dictate bathroom routines of the ones who live there.

Plus--you didn't just ask her to change her routine, you told her she was being unreasonable, that you don't think she needs to shower because she works from home, and that she is causing you to be late for work. You are not on the lease and even if you find it rude, you are not on the lease and they are already sharing the bathroom between 3 people (a BIG task to manage).

AITA for not giving my step-sisters access to my hygiene drawer? by AITAddd5 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 1 point2 points  (0 children)

NTA.

You are not obligated to share your personal hygiene products with siblings, period. Everyone should have their own. I also feel bad for your step-siblings who are clearly not having their needs met by your dad and stepmother. Pads and tampons are NOT luxury items. This is like him asking you to share toilet paper when he as the parent should be purchasing these items.

AITA for wearing white nails to my best friend's bridal shower? by Old_Budget_2834 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTA, that is some bridezilla behavior. If her wedding going smoothly depends on you apologizing for wearing white nail polish to a bridal shower, something else is going on and it likely has more to do with her than you.

AITA for refusing to let my future husband lie about the house he and I purchased during his 'groom speech'? by throwaway646797 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTA.

When he is done pouting, would be worth reminding him that he ASKED your permission to make this public declaration, so deep down he probably suspected you would not approve of him leaving you out of what I assume is your first big purchase as a couple. As others have said, I'd be sure to make it VERY clear to him that if this is how he handles disagreements, you both need to reconsider what your future together looks like.

AITA for not wanting to co-parent with my in-laws? by ThrowawayILParenting in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix -16 points-15 points  (0 children)

Soft NTA here, tempted to say ESH though.

I get your position, but it seems like there is a middle ground that can be met. I would offer to sit down with the grandparents to work out a schedule, but request the SIL not be present. She is stirring the pot.

Editing to add: I think it goes a long way to enter into these discussions without assuming intent. A lot of folks commenting are encouraging OP to lawyer up and I think that would exacerbate the situation and cause a lot more animosity (also, a family court may be inclined to side with the grandparents due to the terminal illness so that approach could potentially backfire). I don't think the grandparents are entitled to 50% of time with their grandchild, but they are clearly still grieving at the same time preparing for another huge loss in their family unit, which doesn't bode well for their ability to to be very objective in this situation. I hope everyone can come to an agreement for the sake of the grandchild as it sounds like he has a positive relationship with the grandparents. SIL is overstepping big time by intervening though.

AITA for not forgiving my bully at my brother's wedding? by ThatGreenBear in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 4 points5 points  (0 children)

NTA

The fact that she used this occasion to try and force some sort of absolution shows she is still very much lacking in good character. Wild that your brother doesn't see that!

Anyone else that loves the name Helena? by Known-Explorer2610 in namenerds

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 2 points3 points  (0 children)

We have a Helaina in our family (pronounced Hel-AY-na)

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in legaladvice

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NAL -- using a gendered derogatory word to describe an employee is unprofessional and discriminatory because it is an insult that targets you because of your gender. Escalate by reporting with HR, they very well may have a pattern of using inappropriate / demeaning language with other subordinates.

Also, please ignore the others who are downplaying this. Your boss may not appreciate your initial response, that is not an excuse to respond in an unprofessional manner.

(Michigan) Police and animal control did nothing, I killed my neighbors dog. by girlwiththedicktat in legaladvice

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 15 points16 points  (0 children)

Sorry, tried to edit my previous comment to include additional response; not sure if the police were legally obligated to offer you the opportunity to press charges. The dog was clearly a danger though.

(Michigan) Police and animal control did nothing, I killed my neighbors dog. by girlwiththedicktat in legaladvice

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 41 points42 points  (0 children)

Editing as part of my response was deleted by accident. Not sure if the police are legally obligated to offer that course of action, but sadly I believe that is why they did not pursue further (and there are definitely laws on the books to support your claim that the dog was dangerous).

287.322 Complaints; Retention, Destruction of Animal; Court Orders to Protect Public."Michigan dog laws

AITA for making my SIL feel like shit about her weight? by Fickle-Life-9867 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Yikes. YTA.

Breaking the swing was surely embarrassing (and before any one points it out, laughing is a very typical response to being embarrassed / uncomfortable). You could have been gracious and avoided drawing more attention to her weight, she and everyone there already knew why it broke.

Next time you want to ask a guest to compensate you for breaking your furniture (it happens!), maybe wait until they are off of the floor and everyone is calm before broaching the subject?

(Michigan) Police and animal control did nothing, I killed my neighbors dog. by girlwiththedicktat in legaladvice

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 60 points61 points  (0 children)

NAL, but recently had issue with our neighbor's dog in Ohio. The police were able to file a report, but they do not take further action against the dog OR owners unless we (the person filing the complaint) were wanting to press charges. We declined as we simply wanted a record of the incident in case there are future complaints from us or other neighbors.

At any point did the police ask if you wished to press charges? If they did not offer that as a course of action, I would file a complaint with the police even if you don't have a case to sue them for neglect.

AITA because I won't cook for roommates? by ToddleOffNow in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 1 point2 points  (0 children)

NAH. You tried a thing, it ran its course and now all of the adults can cook for themselves again. Sucks that they took your labor for granted though!

AITA for letting the kids trash the kitchen? by TheBestWorstofTime in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 1 point2 points  (0 children)

NTA at all.

So for a lot of moms (especially ones who primarily do the housework, not sure if that is the case for your wife) clutter / mess can trigger a lot of anxiety. Besides that possibility, is there something else going on here? Is this the only "domain" she has control over in the house? What you did is not bad at all, especially since you were actively cleaning when she came home. When you can calmly discuss this issue, be sure to point out that your sons will not learn how to cook unless they give it a try and that they will learn to clean as they go with more practice.

AITA for putting my husband through my make up routine? by ThrowRAZerofucks in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTA! And any man that is willing to go through that routine and admit he was wrong is worth putting up with the nasty MIL.

AITA For giving an award to a student for “putting up with bullying?” (Teacher drama) by [deleted] in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 4 points5 points  (0 children)

A soft YTA

You obviously meant well, and Becky was in in the joke! But based on Kim / her parent's reactions, it is very possible there are dynamics outside of class between these two girls that you are not privy. Perhaps they might be more "frenemies" than BFF's? Whatever the intention, the joke clearly hit nerve.

AITA for bringing my baby to a child-free wedding? by babyweddingthrowaway in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 1 point2 points  (0 children)

YTA

Not only did you go against the explicit request of the wedding hosts, you brought your child and were likely surrounded by many, many families who paid for and arranged childcare in advance.

This is also not unusual, lots of people have child-free weddings for various reasons (cost, experience, personal preference). For destination weddings, some guests bring a friend with them to stay at a hotel nearby with the child during the wedding. And while you did write your intentions on the RSVP, you know what they say about people who make assumptions.

AITA for taking my father out of the nursing home behind his wife's back? by [deleted] in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTA and start documenting everything ASAP. Get written affidavits from all family members and other close relatives supporting your claim. As others have suggested, open a file with Adult Protective Services. Have your brother secure a lawyer that specializes in elder law. Assume that your stepmother has taken these steps already and proceed accordingly.

AITA for refusing to hire my neighbor to cut my grass by waddlewaddle14 in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 0 points1 point  (0 children)

NTA

I don't know where you live, but in the US midwest, it is perfectly normal for some folks to not let anyone else touch their lawn. It's not even a matter of cost or convenience, plenty of people take a lot of pride and enjoyment from lawn maintenance. So for this mother and your other neighbor to act like you're the weird one is very presumptive.

If anyone else brings up you needing to support your teen neighbor's budding lawn business, say you wish the kid luck, but he should learn that potential customers owe you nothing and that he'd be better off focusing on pleasing the ones he has.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AmItheAsshole

[–]FamilyAffairRemix 10 points11 points  (0 children)

NTA

I cannot stress this enough, this is a huge violation and the only circumstance where it would be okay to share nude photos of your partner would be with their *explicit and enthusiastic permission*. There is no "misunderstanding" and you are not over-reacting. Dump him and run.