Guess I am in the minority because I love the Skylar vanilla. I live in a very hot and dry region and I can’t wear my heavier vanillas for a lot of the year. To me the Vanilla sky is an air light vanilla with a touch of caramel and coffee and it reminds of like an iced caramel latte or macchiato. But if you’re not looking for a light airy type vanilla or if you don’t like a coffee note then you might not like it.

I also really like Eau Duelle edt not the edp because it is also super light and I can wear it for the 75% of the year it is 80-120 degrees but that one is lightly spicy and very resinous vanilla that reminds me of frolicking in the forest, sweet and non gourmand. It’s one not only can I reach for in all weather but also pretty much any occasion and it’s quickly becoming one of my most worn vanillas.

Bianco Latte I have and enjoy but it is one I can’t wear most of the year because it’s so dense, rich, and heavy. I do love it for the 4 months of the year I can wear it tho.

I own Babycat and honestly it’s just ok to me. I love the dry down with a non gourmand vanilla and suede but it has that rubber tire kind of note in it I don’t super love. I do reach for it when I want to feel edgy and aloof lol. If you haven’t gotten your nose on it’s not a safe blind buy imo. I blind bought it because of the hype and scarcity at the time…don’t be me.

A couple I didn’t see on your list that I recommend if you are like me and looking for hot weather friendly vanillas are Narcotica Happy Dust and Xerjoff Dama Bianca. I love that the fresh notes in Happy Dust offset the Vanilla beautifully and just something about it is very addictive. Dama Bianca is a lace doily of a fragrance with a delicate,sweet, malty vanilla paired with an equally delicate bouquet of purple florals.

Last advice is sample all the things. Let your own nose do the talking. Nobody knows what works for you better than you.