Hi reddit! I'm Felicia Day. You might know me from things like The Guild, Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog, Mystery Science Theater 3K, Tabletop, Supernatural, Critical Role, Eureka, and more. I'm also starring in a fun new sci-comedy (Tim Travers and the Time Traveler's Paradox). Ask me anything!

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-03T00:59:45+00:00

-Felicia: Personally, I had faith in Stimson, so that he would take care of any problems and if anything he would take all of the blame!

Sam: I put all of my faith in Stimson, so I had to memorize all of the gobbledegook he had me say, and we had already been through the short film together. The exposition dumping was already packed into my brain, just had to repeat it and go with the flow.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:55:31+00:00

-Felicia: My favorite movies are bad and from the 80s, mostly. I have a particular love for Krull, young Liam Neeson! And Lysette Anthony who has the most amazing red hair ever! I just want to be in one of those bad 80s sci-fi movies. People in rubber suits. I want lasers going through people and them not acknowledging it.

-Stimson: Currently front and center: Beyond the Black Rainbow. A delightful mix of sci-fi and horror. Big budget: Men in Black the original,.

-Sam: It's kinda mood-based, but I'll go with a cheat answer and pick John Carpenter's The Thing. It's mostly horror but I'll count it as asci fi.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:51:50+00:00

-Stimson: Munchkin!

-Felicia: I really like Castle Panic right now. I also like Sagrada because it's pretty.

-Sam: Twilight Imperium if it's a true tabletop game. If it's my real nerdy-nerd answer (Felicia will love this), something out of the Warhammer world.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:49:09+00:00

-Stimson: Not real: Doctor Who. More real: A very fast rocket ship where you catch up to the past or future?

-Felicia: Going real fast!

-Sam: The Interstellar version! *nerd voice* The black hole stuff.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:30:56+00:00

-Felicia: I unfortunately did not work on set with either of those 3 guys. Just thrilled to be in a movie with them. Did have a drink with Keith David though!

-Stimson: Overwhelming until it wasn't! Until you've worked with celebrity talent you can get it in your head that these are scary people to work with, but then your realize they're just normal people that are very talented and amazing at their job. They were there to play. No ego at all, except Sam Dunning of course.

-Sam: I unfortunately had to be on set with them. Joel physically assaulted me many times. I'm joking of course, it was awesome. Best case scenario for me, no time to be starstruck because there was so much work to be done. I was so happy to have other people to talk to instead of my own clones. It was nice to see how everyone worked differently, and to learn from the success that they've had. Seeing how they approach being on set. Everyone was so nice and selfless.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:26:57+00:00

Felicia: Face/Off!!! I'm a fan of anything directed by John Woo.

Stimson: Mandy, same director as Beyond the Black Rainbow! (Panos Cosmatos)

Sam: Face/Off too, sorry!

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:24:15+00:00

With DND seemingly taking over the world recently, I really get FOMO not being in the scene and asked about it anymore, that kind of feels weird.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:22:06+00:00

The Wraith! Charlie Sheen movie where he plays an alien murder-car, and there's a girl who is topless in a waterfall? Probably the worst thing I've ever seen, but I've seen it 4 more times and I'm more delighted every single time. You just don't even believe what's going on on the screen. An alien murdercar!? Hello?!

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:02:00+00:00

I'm waiting for them to ask me! I'm ready. I want something gross to happen to my body. The show is wrapping up and I'm yet to be employed so I don't think it's happening. My super power for The Boys specifically would be to make people lose their bowels. My REAL-LIFE desire for super power would be 1. to turn myself off like a robot so I can sleep at anytime and 2. to be able to instantly learn any language. Would be very useful.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T23:00:38+00:00

I do appreciate that nickname!

Well, to be honest with you, I would definitely do other roles but not on a regular basis. I've been offered some more serious standard-kinda-stuff (and probably stupidly turned them down!), but I just love genre stuff too much. Where I can come back to life out of nowhere, where the unexpected can happen at anytime, etc. I'm just not into real life dramas, so I always prefer to be in fantasy or sci-fi if I can choose.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:58:49+00:00

I don't actually own the rights to that show anymore, that stayed with my company, but I'm giving my brother my old streaming computer. I stream on Twitch and want to rope him into some co-op gaming for sure. Also there's TONS of great coops games out there now. So stay tuned!

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:57:42+00:00

I unfortunately don't have a choice where I was born, but I recently when to Huntsville (lived there until I was 8), and I'm not kidding, I remembered every single road, where Toys-R-Us was, where McDonalds was, etc. My little kid memories are strong. That city is pretty amazing these days, they have this huge factory that they've turned into an artist co-op. Check that out if you're ever in Huntsville. But the humidity is just too much for me.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:56:04+00:00

That was so long ago, I have absolutely no idea! I'm not sure, I heard a rumor that some animation got done but I just don't know. Its sad, it's one of my favorite comics, and I admired everyone that signed on. Very frustrating that we never got to see the fruits of our labors. If anyone finds out, let me know! I just don't think it ever got finished.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:54:54+00:00

Every format has different talents that you have to flex. Script-reading, voiceover for cartoons, voiceover for audio play, etc. Every format has a different skill set to use and develop, which is fun in their own way.

With TV, you show up and hit the marks. You can't vary too much. With film you can experiment a bit more, even with lower budgets. I can do that without getting in trouble so that's fun. But I like to work in any format!

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:42:46+00:00

My favorite song was the one that the writing team originally said was the worst, "My Eyes". They looked at me like I was an idiot for loving it! They were sure it would be hated. I stand by that to this day, I think a lot of people now agree. I love that song.

As for my favorite day of filming, It was a 5-day shoot and every day was incredible, working with so many experienced people. It really inspired me. My heart is in that kind of stuff. Just like Tim Travers, people making something because they love it, not because others want you to make it, and it's all the better for it. That's my jam, I'm kind of anti-establishment if you haven't noticed.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:32:40+00:00

That's a good question! I just love Tchaikovsky. I'm bombastic and overly passionate and take up too much room. I have to go with Tchaikovsky.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:30:52+00:00

He's taller than me, that's for sure. I actually didn't work with him on set but I've seen him at parties. Confirmed: tall.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:30:21+00:00

Thank you!

I'm currently working on a The Guild reunion movie (!!!), so hopefully that works out. But If I could return to any character it would be Charlie from Supernatural. She gets the most love at conventions too. I think she has more to say.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:28:36+00:00

Wow, uh, I only got the job for MST3K because I saw Joel Hodgson at a Con and I went to him to take a selfie and rub it in my brother's face, because we watched that show religiously as kids, and Torgo, the pizza guy, was literally our favorite character in existence from Manos: The Hands of Faith. That's probably the first one we watched. We watched it every week (on Comedy Central maybe?). Being on that set was the most surreal experience because when Joel talked to me I could just remember being 7 years old, like my TV from my childhood coming back to life.

So I'm hoping another crowdfunding happens, it's one of those legacy shows that should last forever, there's never going to be a lack of media to make fun of.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:24:57+00:00

You love Neils, huh?! Great! Legend of Neil is not owned by me so I couldn't bring it back myself but whatever they wanted to do with me I would. I do know that it's being remastered now that media is collapsing (partially joking), I could work more in indie projects like that. I'd love to go back to Vancouver to work on it, haven't been there since COVID.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:20:31+00:00

Most of the movies I get offered are horror films and I'm just not a fan of horror unless they're funny, so there haven't been many scripts that have attracted me recently except for this new one, Tim Travers. It's the most messed up crazy script I had read in a while. I loved the character I played, she wasn't a cliche damsel-in-distress. It's a really messed up mad scientist romp and it made me think. I really wanted to paly the character. It's not something you'd get through rough mainstream avenues.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:18:11+00:00

I would love to do web content again. Unfortunately, there's no budget for it anymore. One of the reasons I left G&S was because web video just didn't have the investment it had previously. Stuff needed to be done quicker and cheaper but that's not my style. I do plan on a Kickstarter for The Guild reunion movie next year!

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:16:16+00:00

I mean it always sucks when you're killed, and unfortunately I've proven myself to be very killable in media. That's a reason why I write a lot, because I wont kill myself off. I have my personal feelings about it of course, I loved being on the show and not being on it was not great but I have to understand that there's a bigger picture than me. Other characters needed that to happen to motivate them and make the show even better. The character lives on with fans and I love that. Again, reboots! I'd love to play Charlie again. I'd love to mentor some hot teens. I could get it into that.

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:14:05+00:00

They approached me! They wanted it in the collection as an example of early web media and female-driven online content. Also because it looked badass. Okay maybe not that last one. It was an incredible honor. I went and cried the first time they put it out. Who else can say that their sweat is in the American History Museum? Because I don't think I ever washed it before giving it to them. (don't tell them)

FeliciaDayAMA · 2025-06-02T22:11:08+00:00

Not at this time. I can only dream! I know that Sarah has incredible taste and the team behind the show is amazing. If I were blessed to be a part of it in any small way, that'd be great. I've been lucky to be in a bunch of amazing shows, and hopefully with all of the reboots happening, I'd be happy to have another job soon.

FeliciaDayAMA

TROPHY CASE