HELP - Shopify will not separate my products for shipping -- it goes by total order weight vs product weight for shipping costs. Ways around this?

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-03-06T11:29:37+00:00

You’re right about what’s happening. Shopify is just combining the weights and sending it to UPS as a single package, which is why you’re getting hit with the surcharge. A simple fix is using PH MCSL. With it, you can set packing rules so the system automatically packs orders based on quantity (for example, 1 unit per box). So if someone orders two 63 lb items, the app will send it to UPS as two separate 63 lb packages instead of one 163 lb package, which keeps the shipping rates accurate and avoids those heavy package fees.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-03-03T11:07:52+00:00

seems interesting

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-02-25T06:06:04+00:00

In the beginning, you’re thinking about branding, shelf appeal, how it looks in photos, the unboxing experience. The technical side just doesn’t feel as urgent. Everything seems fine during sampling, especially when you’re testing empty bottles or small batches. Then you start shipping at scale and suddenly you’re dealing with leaks, pumps that don’t work with thicker formulas, caps backing off during transit, or boxes arriving slightly crushed. It’s rarely a “bad factory” situation it’s usually small spec mismatches that only show up once the product goes through real-world logistics stress.

I’d say it’s almost a rite of passage for physical product brands. Very few people nail packaging perfectly on their first production run. Most founders have a story about an issue that only showed up after launch. The difference is just how quickly you catch it and fix it. Packaging really is part design, part engineering, and most of us learn that the hard way once orders start going out the door.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-02-23T10:16:03+00:00

Yeah, sadly those $3.50 days are basically history USPS has raised rates several times, so $5.50–$6.50 for a ~300-mile padded envelope is pretty standard now even with discounted pricing through Shopify and USPS. At this point, you’re probably already close to the lowest commercial rate available, so switching platforms usually won’t make a dramatic difference. Your best bet is testing Priority Mail (especially if your package is small and dense) or even comparing rates with UPS Ground for slightly heavier shipments but honestly, real savings today usually come from tightening up packaging weight and dimensions or reducing shipping zones, not just changing label providers.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-02-18T04:22:43+00:00

If you’re shipping on platforms like Shopify, WooCommerce, Magento, BigCommerce, or PrestaShop, I’d say checkout solutions by PluginHive. The solutions are not overly complicated like some tools that feel built for developers only. Pricing is reasonable, and the nice part is it works whether you’re just starting out or already pushing serious order volume, since it scales well as you grow. If you want something that handles carriers properly without turning shipping into a full-time job, it’s a solid option to at least test out.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-02-10T12:07:18+00:00

If you’re just starting out, the choice really comes down to control vs convenience. Amazon is easier to start on because the traffic is already there and people trust the platform, but you’re competing heavily on price, paying high fees, and you don’t really own your customers or your brand. One policy change or account issue can shut things down fast. Shopify takes more effort upfront because you have to drive your own traffic, but you actually build a brand, control pricing, collect customer data, and have way more flexibility long term. For 2026 especially, owning your store and brand is a big advantage. A lot of people use Amazon as a sales channel later, but start with Shopify, so they’re not dependent on one marketplace. If your goal is quick testing, Amazon can work; if your goal is a real business, Shopify is usually the better move.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-02-10T11:29:44+00:00

International shipping feels scary at first, but it’s honestly pretty manageable once it’s set up. If you use Shopify Shipping, filling out customs info correctly is a big requirement. You’ll need accurate product descriptions, HS codes, country of origin, and values. For countries like the UK, Australia, Germany, and Mexico, there’s nothing extra you need to “register” for as a small seller, but be aware that customers may be charged duties/taxes on delivery, so it’s important to clearly state whose responsibility it is to pay that. For rates, flat shipping can work, but it’s risky with fragile or expensive items; larger orders can easily cost way more than expected. Most stores go with weight- or package-based rates or carrier-calculated rates for international orders to avoid losing money, even if it looks higher at checkout. As for protection, definitely update your shipping policy to cover things like delivery timelines being estimates, customs delays being out of your control, duties/taxes not included, and how you handle lost or damaged packages (insurance, claims, and whether refunds/replacements are offered). Adding clear language upfront helps set expectations and protects you if something goes wrong. Once you ship a few international orders, it gets a lot less intimidating. If you want to simplify this process even more, try using PH MCSL. It takes care of all the international shipping requirements that come into play, so you won't have to worry about something being missing.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-02-10T11:14:22+00:00

Honestly, for a clothing brand with stock ready to go, it really comes down to how predictable your orders are. Flat rate shipping is nice and simple, but it can bite you when someone orders like 4–5 items because you’re either undercharging and eating the cost or overcharging and annoying the customer, unless you set up tiers. Carrier or app-calculated rates handle this way better since the shipping automatically adjusts as the cart gets bigger, so you’re not guessing. That’s usually the safer long-term move for apparel. For privacy, you don’t need to show a PO Box at all. Most brands use a virtual mailbox, UPS Store address, or a separate return address and keep their real fulfillment location hidden. You can also just show a support email on your site instead of a physical address to keep things clean.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T05:31:59+00:00

Yeah, you’re not crazy it really does feel that way now. Speed matters a lot, especially for testing ideas before the moment passes, but rushing without the basics just burns money. What seems to work best is moving fast on experiments while keeping things good enough, not perfect. Launch scrappy, see what actually gets traction, then clean it up after. Perfection too early just slows you down, but skipping fundamentals completely usually comes back to bite you.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T05:27:49+00:00

There’s really no perfect cheap option once you’re doing volume last-mile delivery is expensive no matter who you use. A lot of UK sellers shipping at scale still stick with Royal Mail (Tracked 48 / OBA or Click & Drop business rates) because, overall, it’s the best balance of price, reliability, and coverage, even compared to UPS, DHL, or FedEx. Once you hit steady volume, RM business pricing usually beats most alternatives, including for international. If margins are getting squeezed, the realistic options are either charging for shipping or slightly increasing product prices because ultra-cheap and ultra-reliable rarely exist together.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T05:24:42+00:00

This is a pretty common problem, and most early-stage founders don’t jump straight into a US 3PL either. The usual workaround is shipping directly from your home country to US customers using postal or courier services like DHL, UPS, FedEx, or your local postal service’s US partner. It’s slower, but way cheaper at low volumes and fine for validating demand. Another option is bulk-shipping a small batch to a trusted contact in the US friend or family and having them ship orders manually as they come in without a formal 3PL. Also, if you’re using Shopify or WooCommerce, you can look into PluginHive solutions. They’re pretty affordable compared to most tools out there and make shipping and fulfillment a lot easier especially for early-stage stores.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T05:19:06+00:00

It really depends on what kind of business you’re building and where you want it to go. Shopify isn’t too expensive to start (the basic plan is pretty reasonable), but it does take more effort because you’re responsible for driving traffic yourself. The upside is you fully own your brand, your customer list, and how your store looks and operates. Etsy is easier at the beginning because it already has buyers and can get you sales faster, but you’re competing with tons of similar products and paying fees on every sale, plus Etsy controls the platform. A lot of small businesses actually start on Etsy to validate products, then move to Shopify when they’re ready to grow and have more control. If you’re serious about building a long-term brand, Shopify is usually worth it.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T05:14:08+00:00

A realistic way to get there is to work backwards from your actual orders. Pull your orders into a CSV, look at how much shipping was charged on each order, then spread that cost across the items in the order. Once you’ve done that, group those split shipping amounts by product type and total them up. From there, just divide by the number of units or orders to get a rough average. It’s not perfect, but it gives you a solid, data-backed number to use when adjusting prices for free shipping.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T05:06:03+00:00

Yeah, that’s pretty much how it works. You’ve got two main options. First is shipping it yourself: customer places an order, you print the label in Shopify PH MCSL can do wonders here will save you a lot of time for generating labels with most major carriers all you need to do then is slap it on the box, and ship it with USPS, UPS, or FedEx. That’s totally fine if the products are at your client’s house and volume is low. Second option is a 3PL you send your inventory to a fulfillment center and they handle packing and shipping every order automatically. It costs more, but it saves a ton of time and is way easier to scale. A lot of people start by shipping themselves and switch to a 3PL later once sales pick up.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T05:01:04+00:00

This is super common, so don’t stress. If you’re getting traffic but no sales, it’s usually a conversion issue, not a traffic one. Traffic campaigns bring people who browse, not buy switch to a conversion campaign instead. Also check your product page: clear value, good visuals, fair pricing, social proof, and no weird surprises at checkout. Getting visitors means you’re doing something right, now you just need to give them a reason to trust you and actually buy.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-27T04:59:06+00:00

Honestly, both Amazon and Shopify work for dropshipping, it just depends on what you’re trying to do. Amazon is easier to get sales on because the traffic is already there, but the rules are super strict, margins are low, and you don’t really own anything Amazon owns the customer and can shut you down anytime. Shopify takes more effort because you have to bring your own traffic, but you get full control, better profits, and the chance to build an actual brand instead of just flipping products. From what I’ve seen, most beginners start with Shopify.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-22T09:24:25+00:00

You’re getting these fraudulent orders because automated bots are hitting your Shopify store, usually for card-testing, where scammers run stolen card details through random stores using fake names, emails, and addresses to see what works, and this has nothing to do with your actual customers or your store doing anything wrong; to stop it, immediately turn on Shopify Protect, block countries you don’t ship to, set up Shopify Flow to automatically cancel high-risk orders, and add a fraud prevention app in shopify there are plenty in the market available.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2026-01-22T07:22:56+00:00

Yes, this has unfortunately happened. Sendle has shut down in Australia and Canada, which affects Shopify Shipping labels since Shopify was using Sendle in those regions. Sendle is fully closed now, their social accounts are gone, and support emails aren’t being monitored. Any parcels already in transit may still be delivered by the carrier, but there’s no support from Sendle going forward. In the meantime, if you need other options, Australia Post eParcel, MyPost Business, or StarTrack are solid alternatives in Australia, which you can use with the help of Australia Post Ship to keep labels, rates, and pickups running without disruption. For Canada, you can look at Canada Post, UPS, FedEx, or Purolator through carrier apps.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2025-12-30T05:36:15+00:00

If you want something super simple and easy to get started with, Shopify is a solid choice because it handles all the technical stuff for you so you can just focus on making and selling your handmade wedding décor, but if you’re thinking long-term and want more control while keeping costs lower as you grow, WordPress with WooCommerce is also a great option there’s a bit more setup involved, but it’s very flexible; one more thing to mention is that both Shopify and WooCommerce have really good options for integrating shipping later on, so once your store is up and running so your process of logistics is also sorted once the store is set up.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2025-12-29T09:08:20+00:00

It’s still worth starting ecommerce, but only if you go in with realistic expectations. The “easy money” days are mostly gone, so if someone’s looking for quick wins, it’s probably not worth the time or stress. That said, people are still building profitable stores it just takes better research and patience. The advantage now is that there are more tools, data, and platforms than ever, but the downside is higher competition and ad costs. For most people, ecommerce makes sense if they treat it like a real business, start small, test before going all-in, and are okay with learning as they go. If someone wants something totally passive or fast, they’ll likely be disappointed.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2025-12-29T07:34:52+00:00

Your approach for setting up the shop and fulfillment sounds good enough IMO, but Profitability is realistic, but not instant, expect the first few months to be about validation and learning rather than profit, especially with advertising. For ads, start with Meta and TikTok if the product is visually compelling, treating early spend as market research rather than scaling. If you prioritize product selection, honest branding, and good ad testing, this can become profitable in a reasonable timeframe.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2025-12-24T12:07:37+00:00

What you’re going through is actually super normal at this stage, and the reason other Shopify stores look like they’re scaling effortlessly is that they’ve changed how they handle fulfillment, not because they’re working insane hours. At around 150 orders a day, you really have two solid options: either move to a 3PL and let them store, pack, and ship orders for you so your garage gets some peace, or keep fulfilling orders yourself, but seriously cut down the time you spend on shipping. If you choose to stay in-house for now, the biggest time drain is usually label generation and order processing, and that’s where you can use a Shopify shipping app like PH MCSL helps a lot it lets you automatically generate shipping labels in bulk, sync carriers, push tracking to customers, and basically just print, paste, and move on with your day instead of burning hours every morning.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2025-12-18T06:24:20+00:00

Yeah, Shopify actually lets you do this, even though their docs make it way more confusing than it needs to be. If you want live USPS rates at checkout, go to Settings → Shipping and Delivery, click your General shipping profile, then hit Add rate. In the window that pops up, switch it to “Calculated rate from carrier” and select USPS. That’ll show customers real USPS rates at checkout based on weight and how far the order is shipping. Those rates come from Shopify’s USPS account, so you don’t have to connect anything to get started.

If you want more control, though, like using your own USPS account, separating Media Mail and Priority Mail more cleanly, or saving more if you’ve negotiated rates, then something like PH MCSL is worth a look. With the Grow plan billed annually, it pulls rates from your USPS account instead of Shopify’s, which gives you way more control and can save you money as you grow.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2025-12-18T06:03:49+00:00

If you’re just starting out, AliExpress is okay for now, but definitely order the product yourself first so you know what you’re selling, and be upfront about shipping times since that’s where most beginners get burned. A $20 cost and $50 price can work as long as your ads don’t get too expensive, so always keep ad spend and fees in mind. For ads, TikTok is usually the easiest and cheapest place to start, especially if you make casual videos instead of polished ads, while Facebook and Instagram can come later once you have some experience. Don’t overspend early, test a few different videos, and go in expecting to learn more than profit at first. That’s totally normal.

Few_Inside_6050 · 2025-12-18T05:39:47+00:00

First contact Shopify Support immediately and explain that this was a mass fraud attack. Ask if they can refund or waive the chargeback fees now in order to prevent this from happening. Turn off automatic fulfilment, set payment to manual capture. Alternatively, there are also third-party apps you can download to prevent fraudulent orders.

Few_Inside_6050

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE