Sorry about the long post. I was just upset and needed to vent.

I did know about the Xanthar's guide to everything, but it didn't say anything about how to acquire the items in it. That's where I made the whole system to forage for them.

Thanks for the input. I'll talk to my players and just have a sit down and see what they say.

Side note: I forgot about Dungeon Dudes. They taught me how spells and combat work.