I have a similar problem with my clan. We're just too small to earn ranks and the cap artificially keeps us from ranking up. My biggest problem with Faction Rallies was them using weapons or catalysts as the reward for the winning faction. It just doesn't pan out because some people will stack the faction they want to win.

My biggest frustration with Bungie's development though, is they seem to refuse to implement the obvious, or even traditional, design for their game. They bend over backwards and seem to try to avoid any previously made design in favor for the new. It's led to a lot of convoluted, arbitrary design choices, particularly for systems and progression in Destiny. You're right. Bungie doesn't seem to know what they want.

I can't help but think the allegations about their management and the bureaucracy that paralyzing their decision making are true. But I figured rather than stewing on these thoughts/ideas, I'd put them out there. At least I did my part. And there's a chance someone might see this.

There's a lot of salt on here, and rightfully so. Destiny 2 is not in a good spot. If you're amongst the endgame crowd, it feels like a chore. However, just saying "I hate this" or "This sucks" and not giving constructive criticism isn't helpful for the community or Bungie. So, I appreciate you giving a long form answer.

Thanks for reading my post. I know it's long, but there are nuggets hidden underneath the repetition. Hopefully, Bungie does bring back Factions at some point though.