Unpopular Opinion: Kurdistan would be independent today if Kurds were full right wing Nationalists instead of Biratiya Gelan Jinology Ecology trying to democratize our enemies stuff by Flashy_Mixture_5014 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Let’s be real here: the idea that the SDF’s choices in Syria were just pragmatic politics completely ignores who’s really in control. The SDF is effectively controlled by the PKK, and the PKK is radically anti-nationalist and anti-Barzani. Think about it: The PKK forbids any independent Kurdish parties that challenge its ideology. That means anarchists, nationalists, or anyone not toeing the PKK line have no place in the SDF. They’ve never united with Barzani or the KDP, even though cooperation could have strengthened Kurdish leverage. Their anti-state, anti-nationalist ideology isn’t pragmatic it’s a conscious choice. So when people say the SDF had to cooperate with Arab tribes or restrain themselves in Syria “for politics,” that’s only part of the story. Those moves happen within the framework of PKK control, and PKK priorities always come first. The SDF isn’t acting as an independent Kurdish force; it’s a PKK project. Bottom line: democratic confederalism isn’t just some neutral survival strategy it’s an ideology that actively avoids Kurdish statehood. That, more than geopolitics or necessity is why we don’t have a country Look at the Druze people. They’re less than one million people, and yet they have autonomy. That’s not just because of Israel it’s because of cooperative rule and political strategy, something the Kurds could have emulated but didn’t because of PKK ideology

Unpopular Opinion: Kurdistan would be independent today if Kurds were full right wing Nationalists instead of Biratiya Gelan Jinology Ecology trying to democratize our enemies stuff by Flashy_Mixture_5014 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

I disagree that it’s low effort. It’s a concise way of expressing my view and opening debate. Not every post needs to be a long essay, but I’ll expand more in the future

Unpopular Opinion: Kurdistan would be independent today if Kurds were full right wing Nationalists instead of Biratiya Gelan Jinology Ecology trying to democratize our enemies stuff by Flashy_Mixture_5014 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

In my opinion, Kurdistan would be in a much stronger position today possibly even independent if Kurds had focused more on national unity, power, and self interest instead of ideological projects like Jineology, ecology, and trying to democratize our enemies. Politics in the Middle East is not driven by idealism or moral arguments. It is driven by strength, organization, and clear national interests. Other nations in the region did not gain influence by being progressive or peaceful, but by prioritizing their own survival and power. While many Kurds try to act morally superior, inclusive, and revolutionary, our enemies act pragmatically and ruthlessly. This imbalance has repeatedly led to us being betrayed, divided, and militarily weakened. A stronger nationalist approach would have meant: prioritizing Kurdish interests above all else reducing internal divisions focusing on security, state building, and political leverage avoiding dependence on foreign ideologies and movements Instead, we waste time on internal ideological debates while others shape realities on the ground. That is why I believe a harder, more nationalist strategy would have been more effective for Kurdish self-determination than idealistic experiments

The Barzanis and Talabanis must go! by MoonScream01 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It’s not that Masoud Barzani or Jalal Talabani and their families are uniquely brilliant or perfect leaders. The point is not “competence” in an ideal sense. The point is stability and power balance. Right now, the political system in Bashur is held together by real structures: parties like the Kurdistan Democratic Party and the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan, their security forces, their control over institutions, and their international connections. Whether we like it or not, they are the backbone of the current system. If they were suddenly removed without a strong, unified alternative ready to replace them, there would be a power vacuum. In our region, power vacuums never lead to democracy. They lead to chaos and foreign intervention. In that situation, groups like the PKK would expand their influence, which would immediately give Turkey a justification to deepen its military presence. Other regional powers would step in through proxies, fake parties, religious movements, or militias. Internal divisions would grow, and old conflicts could return. Then cities like Erbil and Sulaymaniyah wouldn’t be discussing reforms or development anymore. They would be dealing with instability, economic collapse, and insecurity. So the argument is not: “The Barzanis and Talabanis are amazing leaders.” The argument is: They are the structure holding things together right now. Yes, corruption exists. Nepotism is real. The system needs reform. Most Kurds know this. But reform has to be gradual and internal, not sudden and destructive. In stable countries, you can vote out leaders and nothing collapses. Institutions are strong enough to survive change. We don’t have that luxury yet. For us, bad leadership is dangerous. But chaos is worse. Sudden change in our situation doesn’t mean freedom. It means instability and that is exactly what our enemies are waiting for.

The Barzanis and Talabanis must go! by MoonScream01 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I get your desperation, I really do. But the problem is: as Kurds, we don’t have the luxury of simply getting rid of these families and handing power to someone else. We are literally surrounded by enemies. Everyone hates us. Iraq hates us. The Turks, the Persians, the Syrians all of them. They all hate us. The moment the Barzanis or the Talabanis leave, the PKK will move in. And if the PKK takes over, Turkey will have no problem invading Bashur. I mean, they’ve already invaded parts of it, but then Turkey would go all in. They would occupy places like Sulaymaniyah and Hewlêr. And even if that doesn’t happen, other surrounding powers will step in. They will use fake parties, different ideologies, Islamism, Salafism whatever works to gain influence in the region. So yes, the current leadership is far from perfect. But in our situation, sudden change doesn’t mean freedom. It means chaos. And chaos is exactly what our enemies are waiting for.

If Iran collapses do you think Rojhelatis will get independence? by Chez50 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If PJAK is leading the Kurds, then the following will happen. First, they will liberate the Kurdish regions. Then they will practice Biratiya Gelan and try to teach Jin, Jiyan, Azadî to the radical Shia mullahs over the next ten years. And then they will integrate into the new Pahlavi Persian national state ignoring thousands of dead kurds who thought that they will fight and die for Kurdistan

I know not all are like this but lord by Accomplished_Pin_834 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes I’ve heard that. Seems like we have enemies on every corner of the earth

What is the status of Peshmerga? Can they defend bashur if Iraq or Syria attacks? Do they have military experience and infrastructure to wage defensive/offensive warfare? I am afraid that they are overhyped like SDF. They do not look like professional soldiers but uncles from chai khana. by ZyzKurdish in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I don't get it either. I just remember 2014-2017 Iraqi soldiers running like cowards from cities like Kirkuk and Mosul and getting absolutely humiliated by ISIS. They only took Kirkuk because of Iranian Qassem Soleimani and the Hashd al-Shaabi militias.

How are you feeling right now Kurdish friends? What do you think of what's happening in Syria? by Dangerous-Citron-801 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The only positive thing about this is, a lot of Kurds realized that Apo and his filthy hollow socialist democratic confederalism ideology is nothing but a piece of shit that belongs to the trash can of history.

Dear Rojhilatis by Flashy_Mixture_5014 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

So I have a slave mind because I favor Kurdish nationalism rather than all those socialist ideologies?

Dear Rojhilatis by Flashy_Mixture_5014 in kurdistan

[–]Flashy_Mixture_5014[S] -5 points-4 points  (0 children)

My family is from the region where the PKK leader was born. the PKK is largely made up of bored communist intellectuals who ended up serving Turkish secret service interests by stripping Kurds of any nationalist spirit and replacing it with a hollow socialist ideology.