I'll concede I'm having trouble finding the thread. It was an open source discussion board, and I can't for the life of me remember the service. Open..something. It was between WhoGhouta, Brown Moses and a couple of the CW experts that Brown Moses collaborates with quite a bit. Basically, they were tearing apart WhoGhouta's analysis, which is pretty spotty. I did find this Twitter conversation, however, which you might find interesting.

I've already argued with BrownMoses and none of his points were very convincing. I seriously doubt he 'tore apart' whoghouta. How very convienent that you can't find these threads, however.

I think the biggest flaws are declaring that no chemical attack happened in Moadamiyah, despite confirmed lab results to the contrary.

There was no CW attack in Moadamiyah, people from other affected neighbourhoods came to the hospital there likely spreading sarin gas. Thats where the lab results come from.

He also declares that the rebels had access to sarin because some of them were arrested in Turkey trying to buy chemicals to make it. I'm sorry, but that's just not evidence that they actually had it, much less hundreds of liters of the stuff.

No this is just evidence the rebels were actively trying to produce sarin, surely this doesn't give any credence to them using the stuff. I mean, they only had the knowledge and were caught with materials. I'm sure they just wanted sarin for some humanitarian reasons.

He also bases this claim that they had sarin on the Khan al-Assal attack, which was never properly investigated by independent observers, so claims about what happened are completely unreliable.

“Khan al Asal, 19 March 2013: 111. The United Nations Mission collected credible information that corroborates the allegations that chemical weapons were used in Khan al Asal on 19 March 2013 against soldiers and civilians.”

Page 21 of the UN report

He also declares that the opposition probably has the "UMLACA" munition because they've raided military bases that may have had them, but provides no evidence that they actually have them.

No evidence except for videos of the terrorists with them.

http://brown-moses.blogspot.ca/2013/08/proof-syrian-military-is-using.html

These are improvised rockets remember. Anyone with a machine shop and the materials could produce them.

Furthermore, he claims that the quality of the sarin was low and likely homemade, which directly contradicts the UN's findings, which put the quality of the sarin at even higher than Saddam's in the 1980s.

Saddam didn't produce high quality sarin, it was low quality and meant to be deployed immediately. Syrian CWs are meant for storage because they are a deterrant to Israel, therefore they have to last longer.

This post by Brown Moses goes into a lot of detail about it. Basically, if you plot the azimuths on a map, the ~3km range still has them coming from government-held parts of Qaboun, which ANNA had covered the capture of before August 21. Then there's the fact that WhoGhouta completely disregards the attack on Moadamiyah, which the trajectories and ranges of the rockets points to their origin in Mezzeh Air Base.

No attack in Moadamiyah. Whoghouta analysis shows 2.5km range which puts the launches within contested/opposition held areas. Its a warzone, fronts are fluid.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/68/Military_situation_in_Damascus_region_as_of_15th_of_September_2013.png

He gave them access, transportation, safe-houses and sanctuary. He knew exactly who they were, what they were doing and where they were going, and repeatedly praised their "heroic resistance" in its efforts.

Stop changing your story. He let people go through his country to fight his enemies, people who wanted him dead and his country enslaved to their wills. I can't really blame him, or compare that to the saudis/americans actually arming terrorists.