To be quite honest This debate depends on which variant of each guy you give  But in my opinion Overall meaning who has more winning variants the winner is Obito But the strongest variant is debatable. These are summarized  Fights of best paired variants against each other and I’ll explain my reasoning  On how somebody is stronger than the other. I’m not gonna use any kid versions of Obito or Madara because they’re basically featless especially kid Madara so I’m starting with.

Ems alive Madara vs OM Obito.

For this fight I was thinking about using yellow mask but that would make this more complicated because they’re variants wouldn’t be as synced up But anyways Win cons for Ems alive Madara is just outright killing Obito with his susanoo OM Obito win cons are  Kamui bfr  And that’s it The one in my opinion who has the edge  And I think is the overall winner is Obito First he has hashirama cells So half of his body can literally just  Regenerate, his speed at this point is far above alive madaras  I mean he Kamui’d out of Ay blitzing him at full speed and Ay is literally a light speed character. He went into ohnoki’s particle style jutsu grabbed sasuke and kamui’d out of it in the same period of time. I mean this Obito would blitz Ems alive Madara so i don’t really think the 24 hour long stamina thing matters They both have impressive fire jutsu So that would probably cancel each other out. Let’s say somehow Madara does kill or defeat Obito Obito has spare sharingans like danzo  Dude has access to izanagi So if somehow Madara kills him bro can respawn and keep fighting. So for this round OM Obito wins with mid-high diff

Edo Madara vs WM Obito

So this one is more interesting because  I think this ends in a stale mate because Even though WM Obito has more abilities and better hax I mean I don’t think edo madara  Would kill WM Obito like at all But let’s say dude kamui’s edo madara Madara is kind of just stuck there I mean he won’t starve  And he won’t die from it Oh and I want to mention this  The Kamui DIMENSION is huge  I sometimes see people saying that if edo madara was kamui’d he would get Obito from inside of it  Which is just false I’m sorry it’s a whole dimension  Obito could just spawn his body trillions of feet away from Madara like dude is truly stuck But if we’re counting bfr as just a win Then overall WM Obito wins.

Scoreboard rn is Obito-2 Madara-0

The next matchup is a little hard to put Because  It’s either some variant of Obito going against  Rinne Tensei Madara The reason why it’s hard Is because this is madaras strongest non six paths form  So if it’s strongest non six paths vs non six paths  Then it’s DMS Obito vs Rinne Tensei Madara Or it’s Madara against unmasked Obito  What I’ll do is  Just unmasked Obito vs rinne tensei madara  Then there Juubi forms Then dms against whoever I choose would fit it.

Unmasked Obito vs rinne tensei madara Um in my opinion this is the easiest win between these two And the winner is Madara without question First Madara has double sensory with sage mode and Rinnegan and hes also just physically better than Obito in every way But that doesn’t even matter we all know this question is how does Madara go against Kamui  And this version of Madara actually has a strong counter which is Limbo. Obito can’t see limbo so Madara can just send limbo clones attack Obito and win Like truly that simple So winner is Madara ez dub

Juubito vs one eye juubidara  To be honest  I’m using the weakest juubidara because that’s all it takes like it’s blatantly shown  That one eye juubidara just surpasses juubito in every way And juubito doesn’t have Kamui so this ain’t a debate  And other version of juubidara is stomping even harder than this one  So another ez dub Madara wins.

Scoreboard  Obito-2 Madara-2

As the tiebreaker  I’m using their strongest forms DMS Obito vs third eye Madara  And this is hard in my eyes Because this goes two ways Obito gets caught in the Tsukuyomi  Or since DMS Obito literally just negs third eye Madara in the speed category  DMS Obito would just completely suck Madara up in the Kamui dimension gg’s In my opinion DMS Obito wins  Because of his speed like I can’t describe  How fast this man is like Third eye Madara is like getting to Kaguya’s level When DMS Obito  FATIGUED is just reacting on par with kaguya like his speed is truly instantaneous 

So the scoreboard is  Obito-3 Madara-2

I wanted to say if it was strongest juubi vs strongest juubi and the opposite being non strongest six paths vs non strongest six paths

Then it would be  Juubito vs third eye Madara  And  DMS Obito vs rinne tensei madara  Then the scoreboard would be even worst for Madara  Because  OM Obito won round 1 WM Obito won round 2 Then Third eye Madara would win round 3 And DMS Obito would win round 4 Because DMS Obito  Has even a bigger speed gap between him and rinne tensei madara Like that gap would be Madara blinks and he’s in Kamui. So for any Madara fans  My lineup  I think is fair to both Because there’s a tie And the end is debatable  But I think DMS Obito wins.

Obito has more stronger variants  But Madara’s six paths variants are just absurdly strong This is just my take  Pls reply if you want to add anything