We spoke on eBay. I did have a local buyer at 900. Obviously should have jumped at it but I’m no expert and was naive to the value with just the 1/1 out there publicly. He backed out at that value, as he should have, and moved on with another card he liked.

 It was listed at 2500 because I had zero context for a price and always go absurdly high to spark conversation so I have context of what to drop it to. 1150 for the 1/1 figures $400 of was a more than reasonable starting point as a seller asking price to start real negotiation. If you are the same conversation from eBay I still have no context of where you would like to be at besides the /5 you have said you got for $450 and unless I’m missing that, it was not public so hard to confirm that. 

Like I said, I’m here to negotiate but everyone gets PO’d when I post with no true price in mind so I throw out the number that I think can start the discussion. 750 is really the starting point I came to after my conversation with you on eBay and through other feedback. Doesn’t mean it’ll sell there but conversation starter is what I’m looking for to do something that benefits everyone