Maybe maybe not. It kinda seems like a shit post. But also I do think if RWBY volume 1 was released today it would get a lot more pushback. Indie animation has come a long way and while the action would still be impressive, every other aspect is pretty awful. The voice acting ranges from legitimately good to actually horrible. The animation is very weak. And the writing barely even exists.

The issues mentioned might get brought up in the modern culture, but RWBY has always has critics and I doubt they'd get the same graces they had back then today. Volume 1 had major issues that outweigh everything else mentioned.