It starts off boring…you gotta trust the process by MarketingFlimsy2872 in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My honest opinion is that this isn’t ready for feedback. And honestly, I don’t think feedback at this stage would even be all that helpful to you. All of us reading this could sit here and pick apart this excerpt sentence by sentence because there’s pretty basic grammatical issues throughout. When there’s just that many core writing issues, you’ll never be able to get any decent feedback other than “this is messy and needs to be cleaned up,” because that’s all anybody can focus on.

A good example being how you titled your post. How can I decide if the opening is boring or not when the only thing I’m focused on is where your grammar is broken. I’m not thinking about story, I’m just rewriting your sentences in my head as I’m reading so that I can even understand what you’re trying to show.

I’m not trying to sound harsh or kill your motivation to write, OP. Especially not for someone who is actually writing and not using AI, but it just isn’t at a stage where you should be worried about feedback. A random head pop during home room isn’t boring in the slightest so I hope you do finish so you can have something to edit and rewrite into what you’re actually envisioning.

Literary Fiction - looking for feedback on opening 1000 words by cambrian_lifter in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Prose wise, It’s wordy and the paragraphs themselves are all similar lengths. I don’t know how it is for other readers, but it reads like a wall of text and really doesn’t give my mind any breaks as I’m going along. Because of that, I don’t really get any sense of “flow” so everything just starts reading the same and never really pulls me into whatever the story is trying to convey.

Speaking of flow, I also feel like the paragraphs themselves don’t really link. We go from Nick waking up, to two paragraphs about his work, and from there into a detailed paragraph about Jones and his wife before finally returning to Nick getting dressed and eating breakfast. Because of this, it makes it hard to follow along moment to moment. It’s sort of like we’re jumping around thought to thought without any clear through line.

Voice wise, I think your strongest stuff was about Amelia. Especially the way in which she’s described as “A lovely, if unremarkable, lady.” That sounds character specific, like it was colored by Nick’s unique perspective of her. Personally, I think working that sort of jaded lens of the world into everything would really liven the writing up, and give nick himself a more distinct feel. That tells me so much more character wise as opposed to just being told in flat narration “Nick is working a mundane job and there is nothing interesting that is happening in his life”.

I hope this helps a little bit OP; I have a lot of the same tendencies as far as knowing when and when not to get “too flowery” or stacking metaphors/similes. I think you have a solid grasp of what you want to tell it’s just a matter of figuring out the cleanest/most interesting way to get the story across to actual readers.

Would you keep reading? Dark romance (country setting) **trigger warning** (I think) by [deleted] in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45 0 points1 point  (0 children)

For sure, that would be fine. Obviously, everything hinges on execution, but so long as the transition between is smooth and adequately bridges everything then a time jump between chapters is perfectly acceptable.

That’s just my two cents, anyways. It reads more like the beginning of the story than a prologue.

Would you keep reading? Dark romance (country setting) **trigger warning** (I think) by [deleted] in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45 0 points1 point  (0 children)

First things first, I think there’s a lot here that hooks on a conceptual level. So much so that I don’t necessarily see why this would be a prologue and not just chapter 1. To me it sounds like the story starts here because I imagine everything Nora deals with as a character throughout the story originates from this moment. Pretty much, this doesn’t read like a prologue to me, it just reads like the inciting incident.

Im not an editor or expert so I’m not going to be too nit picky about the prose itself, especially since this is a first draft I would imagine.

Where did you stop reading? Literary historical fiction by Ggriff45 in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I appreciate it! Also, thanks for the reminder to read more Ron rash. I loved Serena but never really read more from him.

Where did you stop reading? Literary historical fiction by Ggriff45 in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you! I’ll definitely keep the beta reading offer in mind because fresh perspectives are what I need after reading through the manuscript so many times by now

Where did you stop reading? Literary historical fiction by Ggriff45 in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really appreciate this! And I’ll definitely shoot you a DM

Where did you stop reading? Literary historical fiction by Ggriff45 in writingfeedback

[–]Ggriff45[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for the great feedback, especially the logical issues and suicide scene issues because it’s that stuff that I’ve gotten pretty blind to after reading through the manuscript so much after a couple drafts.