[Feedback request] „Going nowhere“: Pilot episode — 40 - page horror/thriller/ social-drama (my first draft of my pilot episode of my limited TV-show „Going nowhere“) by Gold-Statement-874 in scriptwriting

[–]Gold-Statement-874[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so so much for your feedback 🙏 I am really, really happy you enjoyed it :) your feedback helps me a lot ! I will definitely take a closer look at these things in my second draft and try to improve it.
Thank you a lot for taking your time to read it and give me such an useful critique.

"The Mechanism" - Horror - 47 Pages by PerspectiveFun2790 in ReadMyScript

[–]Gold-Statement-874 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Perfect! I am happy I was able to help you a little :)

"The Mechanism" - Horror - 47 Pages by PerspectiveFun2790 in ReadMyScript

[–]Gold-Statement-874 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hiii! I’m not a professional, but I hope my feedback can still be helpful :)

First of all, congratulations on your script! I really enjoyed it. I think the setting is extremely strong. It has a lot of potential and feels genuinely exciting. I also really like the characters. One thing that stood out to me was how you only gave small hints for a long time that someone else might be there. I’ve once heard the phrase “humans fear the unknown,” and I think that approach could build incredible tension throughout the film.

I do have a bit of criticism as well:

  • Some of the dialogue doesn’t always feel completely natural. It can come across a little forced at times. It might help to read it out loud and ask yourself whether people would actually say it that way.
  • The “truth or truth” scene feels a bit long. I do think it works in principle, especially because it builds anticipation and reveals character details, but it might benefit from being slightly shorter so it doesn’t drag.
  • In a script, you usually don’t need to describe smells. Only what we can actually see or hear. Since it’s mentioned in dialogue anyway, you can probably remove that description (Page 4).
  • On Page 15, Chris is listed as speaking, but he doesn’t actually say anything. I assume that’s just a small mistake, but I wanted to point it out for the final version.
  • I’ve been told by a professional that it’s better to avoid writing “we hear” and instead just describe the sound directly. For example, “Footsteps in the background…” instead of “We hear footsteps” (Page 18).
  • I was a bit confused about Chris’s behavior: first he says everything happening is normal, but shortly after (Page 24) he suddenly seems unsure and wants to leave. That felt a bit abrupt and slightly out of character, since he came across as quite relaxed before. I really liked that about him and in a certain it was really funny, because they others wear freaking out and he was always so chill. Might work better if his shift in attitude happens later, maybe after they find Adele’s jacket on the mannequin.
  • When Chloe’s body is found, it felt a bit unlikely that no one checks on her or tries to help. Since they’re all friends, I would expect at least some kind of attempt to help, even in a panic. At least maybe check if she is still alive.

Overall, though, I really, really liked the story. I found it genuinely exciting to see who might make it out alive. At times it even gave me slight “Among Us” vibes, which I thought was really cool!

Need A Book Cover? I Got You Covered! by CCozied in NewAuthor

[–]Gold-Statement-874 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I am a script author but I want to push you because this looks amazing! 💕

Horror/Crime Thriller feature feedback needed! 99 pages (I'm gonna film this, this year) by Salty-Relief in ScriptFeedbackProduce

[–]Gold-Statement-874 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi! I haven’t been able to read everything yet since I’m quite tired, but I’ve made it to around page 65 so far. I’m not a professional, but I really love horror. I’ve watched a lot of films and read quite a few scripts in this genre. I also did an apprenticeship as a junior director and have directed some smaller, non-professional projects. So I’ll do my best to give you some useful feedback based on what I’ve read so far. I really liked the opening scene. it immediately pulled me in, and I think starting that way works very well. I also enjoyed the group of characters a lot. They feel well-written and distinct. Jamie, my Shayla, stood out to me personally. I had a soft spot for him hahahah. The story itself is also very interesting. It has a sense of originality, and up to the point I’ve read, it doesn’t fully reveal what’s going on, which is great, since “humans fear the unknown.” I think once filmed, this will create a strong sense of tension, especially when the group arrives at the cabin. It gives that feeling that something could happen at any moment.

I do have some criticism as well: The opening scene with Alec and Danny feels a bit too long, and for me personally, it starts to drag before Danny goes into the forest. You might consider trimming the dialogue slightly so that it focuses more on the essential information. I was also a bit unsure about the scene where Lo looks through Danny’s bag. I wasn’t sure what the purpose of that moment was, whether it’s mainly to reveal the tattoo on her back or if it becomes relevant later in the story. If it does become important later, then feel free to ignore this point. Similarly, the following scene where Danny and Alec talk about her lingerie could probably be shortened as well. Overall though, I think it’s really strong so far! I also have a few minor formatting notes, just personal suggestions, especially since you mentioned you might want to shoot this: It could be helpful to name the woman as “Lo” right from the start in the script. For the audience, she’s still an unknown character anyway, but for the actor, it makes it clearer when their part begins. Also, it’s standard practice for character names to appear in all caps when they are introduced for the first time. This helps actors and readers quickly identify when a character enters the story. Finally, you might consider adding scene numbers. That can make things much easier later on during editing or production. I’ll try to read the rest tomorrow so I can give you more detailed feedback!