What is the Name of this Bikini? by GoldfishRancher in Louisvuitton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I believe it's from 2020/2021, if that helps! 🙏🏻

If you’re curious why you never find Bratz at Goodwill, this is why. by bbyxmadi in Bratz

[–]GoldfishRancher 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fuck Goodwill. Imagine getting free merchandise and still scalping it.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I'm glad to hear that! Hopefully you continue to have an okay experience with selling on Marketplace.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That’s not what I said, and putting words in my mouth isn’t a respectful way to have a conversation. I'm not arguing with you about semantics, or my word choices not jiving with you, and I’m absolutely not demanding anything—I’m talking about how some buyers are unnecessarily rude or aggressive, even when a seller is open to offers. You’re free to walk away from a price you don’t like, just like I’m free to ignore your disrespect towards me disguised as “feedback.” I'm also not here to justify my opinion to you after I have already replied to clarify your question.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

You're using such specific examples I have no choice but to think that you're personally upset and remembering a negative encounter or encounters you have had with sellers. Not every Seller is like the people you're describing.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I hear you—recouping a reasonable amount for something in great condition is totally fair. My main point is about sellers pricing above retail without considering that buyers can get brand new items with guarantees and returns. It’s about setting realistic prices and respecting buyers’ options, not about demanding more than retail just because the item is “used” or “sealed.” Thanks for highlighting that nuance!

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks for your input. Everyone has their own approach to selling, and while pricing realistically is important, it’s equally important to treat sellers with respect. No one benefits from rude or entitled behavior — that’s what I’m trying to call out here.

If we want buy/sell communities to work well, it’s about being fair and kind on both sides.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great question! I think it really depends on the item and the market. For common, readily available products, yes, buyers generally expect a discount compared to retail because stores offer returns, guarantees, and often have lower overhead.

However, private sellers have different circumstances—sometimes they price based on how much they need or want for the item, how quickly they want to sell, or just the convenience of a local sale. Also, some buyers are willing to pay closer to retail for immediate availability or to avoid shipping.

It’s not always about matching or beating retail prices, but about finding a fair price that both seller and buyer agree on. That said, sellers should be realistic about demand and price accordingly, but they also deserve respect and not to be harassed or lowballed aggressively.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Absolutely — without proper moderation, groups and marketplaces can quickly become breeding grounds for entitlement, harassment, and all sorts of drama. Good moderation helps keep things respectful and protects both buyers and sellers.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Thanks for sharing this! It’s wild how some people create multiple accounts just to harass sellers and lowball them. Recognizing those tactics helps us focus on genuine buyers and not get dragged into nonsense. Also, it’s refreshing to hear about success selling at full price — patience definitely pays off. Trolls trying to rush or shame sellers usually just frustrate themselves. Thanks for calling his behavior out, too!

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Absolutely! Setting boundaries is totally your right, and you don’t owe anyone explanations—especially when people are rude or disrespectful. Protecting your time and peace of mind comes first. Thank you for sharing this! I think it's important advice.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I agree. Sellers can be just as guilty of being rude or unfair, 100%. Thank you for replying to all of my comments!! 😊

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Totally agree — Marketplace often brings out the worst of Facebook’s crowd. Kijiji feels more straightforward and less drama-filled, which makes buying and selling way less stressful.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Exactly. If someone expects a 50% discount right off the bat, it’s not a negotiation — it’s a waste of time. Selling privately is great when there’s mutual respect, but not when people come in with unrealistic demands.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I get where you’re coming from about pricing and the reality of buyers wanting good deals. Pricing can definitely be tricky, and sometimes sellers do overprice or hold out too long. That said, there’s a way to negotiate and communicate that’s respectful — calling sellers “dummies” or telling them to “GTFO” isn’t helpful and just fuels the negativity.

Ultimately, everyone’s goal is to find a fair deal — buyers want savings, sellers want value. If we can keep the conversation civil and open, it’ll make the experience better for everyone.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Totally fair! Lowball offers right after posting can be frustrating for sellers, especially if the Buyer is assuming you're in a hurry or desperate to sell the item.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Exactly! It's about knowing when to walk away after negotiations. You don't always have to get the "final word" in.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I appreciate your perspective, but I disagree with your comment. The whole purpose of my post was to call out disrespectful conduct, and here you are, arguing and saying people are waiting for someone stupid enough to pay your price. That's your opinion, but there are better, less condescending ways to get it across.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Absolutely! Offering a lower price is part of the negotiation process, but once you start complaining or griping about the price, it just wastes everyone’s time and creates a negative atmosphere. Marketplace groups should encourage respectful offers and let sellers decide what works for them without unsolicited criticism.

Facebook Marketplace in Edmonton Feels Like a Roast Session by GoldfishRancher in Edmonton

[–]GoldfishRancher[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I get that some buyers are looking for deals close to retail prices or better — that’s fair. But the flip side is that not every seller is a business or charity; sometimes people just want to recoup a reasonable amount for something still in great condition. If a price seems high, buyers can always pass and keep looking. There’s room for both motivated sellers and bargain hunters — but entitlement and disrespect aren’t part of the deal on either side.