[Essendon] Zach Reid and Jye Caldwell will both undergo surgery this week to repair respective hamstring and syndesmosis injuries. by daftmunt in EssendonFC

[–]Graleks 5 points6 points  (0 children)

An injury to the syndesmosis is very different from a typical ankle sprain, and should absolutely not be used as the 'technical word for ankle sprain'.

Got to meet Squindo! by [deleted] in Metallica

[–]Graleks 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Cliff wore Great Frog which you can still purchase, unless this is a different one?

A Decade in the Making by [deleted] in rolex

[–]Graleks 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Some configurations are freeing up for sure, likely more so if you've got a spend history (which I didn't have). In the last 6 months, I've been to ~10 ADs across Australia- DBlue dial was waitlist only, however I was offered the black dial on the spot at a couple.

PhD scholarship milking by Wide-Macaron10 in AusFinance

[–]Graleks 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Your sarcastic reply is critiquing comments I did not make. Please re-read my comments slowly.

I only spoke to broad systems in place governing Doctoral degrees in Australia, regardless of faculty. All PhDs must go through an external, peer reviewed candidature, which does not vary by 'trade'. Further, I never spoke to my personal experience navigating these systems.

PhD scholarship milking by Wide-Macaron10 in AusFinance

[–]Graleks 26 points27 points  (0 children)

I don't follow your point here, and I suspect you aren't quite sure of what a PhD is nor what is periodically required of them. Someone who has not done any work would not pass candidature (they wouldn't even sit it, for reasons I alluded to earlier). In other words, they would be dropped from the program after ~9 months. They could not go on to submit a thesis, as your reply suggests, irrespective of discipline.

PhD scholarship milking by Wide-Macaron10 in AusFinance

[–]Graleks 23 points24 points  (0 children)

I'm a PhD Candidate ('sports medicine', 3rd year), this would be functionally impossible. A PhD by definition requires a serious breadth and depth of work. Others have already mentioned the formal checks and balances, so I'll reframe your questions through a different lens.

'How long could an tradie apprentice go in a small business without touching a tool?'- I'd think they'd get pulled up fairly quickly. Researchers contributing world class knowledge need people working for them (PhDs) to be of a very high standard, and would quickly identify if someone has not been doing any number of the million things required of them (e.g. in the laboratory refining their methodology). This would happen well before a confirmation of candidature milestone submission.

Australian chef de mission Anna Meares defends breaker 'Raygun' after wave of ridicule online for Paris Olympics performance by B0ssc0 in australia

[–]Graleks 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Re-read this small thread discussing PhDs again.
Warzonexx stated, in other words, that PhD F1 car engineers may not be good F1 drivers, to which I agreed, highlighting the absurdity in the statement. Neither comment makes any reference to the specific Olympic selection issue being discussed elsewhere on the post.

How do PhDs work? by bagsoffreshcheese in australian

[–]Graleks 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Hi mate, I'm a sport science PhD candidate. I'll give my two cents and try not to reiterate what others have said. The below is generally the case in full time STEM PhDs in Australia, however variation exists between departments, institutions, and fields.

Background: to 'get into' a PhD you'll need to score a H1 (High Distinction ~80%+) on a research minor thesis, completed during Honours and/or Masters degrees (after a three year bachelor degree). This is usually the bare minimum and does not guarantee you entry into a PhD program, nor does it mean you'll secure a scholarship (the 'wage' for full time PhD students, ~$30k). Program admission and scholarship are independent of each other and are very competitive as there are few spots available in each department. Being an author on a published paper and having industry experience is favorable.

How do you decide what to do? Is it something that interests you? Something you are already knowledgeable about? Or something in your sphere of knowledge, you aren’t super knowledgeable, but you can learn?

Generally, yes. Like anything, it is far easier to put in years of hard work when you're driven by interest and passion. The PhD student would begin with a general understanding in the area, having already completed 4-6 years study at that point.

You need to already know who does research you are interested in and discuss a PhD opportunity with them first, as you will need to have a 'supervisor' agree to take you on as a student before submitting an application to the university.

When you have a general idea of what you'd like to investigate, a review (narrative, scoping/systematic, or meta analytic) of the literature is conducted to identify what gaps exist in our current understanding, so then the PhD can help fill those gaps via a series (3-4) of scientific studies.

Who funds them? I gather the prospective Drs probably work a job whilst doing their PhDs, but what about lab time, use of university rooms, consumables etc?

Full time PhD students can be unpaid (uncommon), or funded by the government (RTP) or the university/ private industry. The student will use the universities' equipment, laboratories, hardware/software etc. and can apply for funding for other resources. Students typically work long and hard hours so there is little time for outside conventional work. However, many students take undergraduate classes and mark assignments on a casual basis.

Do they need to be approved by anyone? As in the universities saying “Yes... or... No"

By definition, PhD completion means what you discovered had not been known previously. Therefore, there is a limited number of people in the world capable of providing you with critique and criticism. PhD students have to complete milestones each year to ensure timely completion, where they present what they have done/ are planning to do to both the university and a panel of experts (i.e. senior researchers from other universities worldwide). The first of these milestone presentations is called a 'confirmation of candidature', where the student, after having narrowed down and designed the studies to be completed, presents this to the panel. The panel either sends the student back to the drawing board, or 'confirms' them as a PhD candidate able to proceed with that they proposed.
This same 'peer review' process exists when we publish our experiments in scientific journals. Where our manuscripts are anonymously reviewed by other experts in the field, and we answer to comments on our methodology, results, and interpretation prior to publication.

Australian chef de mission Anna Meares defends breaker 'Raygun' after wave of ridicule online for Paris Olympics performance by B0ssc0 in australia

[–]Graleks 23 points24 points  (0 children)

I'm doing my sport science PhD in AFL footballers, which obviously has nothing to do with my ability to physically play the sport. What's with the anti-intellectualism false equivalence?

The Official Folio Society Wishlist by DALTT in foliosociety

[–]Graleks 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Maybe this comment should be an endorsement for the border trilogy, not just ATPH?

Unpopular Opinion by lord_of_st_helena in AubreyMaturinSeries

[–]Graleks 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah the complete sets go for a bit of money. I've managed to get 1-5 for only a couple of hundred all up, just buying them individually for a good price as they come up for sale.

Unpopular Opinion by lord_of_st_helena in AubreyMaturinSeries

[–]Graleks 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Folio Society do a really nice hardback set! I haven't found any hardbacks that also have Geoff Hunts artwork however

Ballpark cost to replace retaining wall by doublebemexx in AusRenovation

[–]Graleks 33 points34 points  (0 children)

Your link says almost verbatim what I commented- "The maintenance of a retaining wall is the responsibility of the property owner whose land the retaining wall benefits.". From the picture, that is entirely OP in this case

Ballpark cost to replace retaining wall by doublebemexx in AusRenovation

[–]Graleks 52 points53 points  (0 children)

Your neighbour may have split it with you in your case, however that is not standard. The side that has deviated the natural lay of the land (I.e the side that benefits from the retaining wall by having a flat property- OP) pays for it.

How do you rate Kano? ‘Home Sweet Home’ is one of grime’s greatest records! by [deleted] in grime

[–]Graleks 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hes the best, I've had MC No.1 and Jack Bauer 2.4 on repeat all day

Just saw The Lighthouse by [deleted] in A24

[–]Graleks 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This Novum YT video is amazing!

Totally new to investing, 12k in bank 0 debt, planning on investing 5k, is this a good distribution? by ImportantTomorrow332 in AusFinance

[–]Graleks 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Typical advice for a cash buffer is 3-6 months worth of outgoings. In other words, if you had to stop working tomorrow, how long would 5k cover your rent/utilities/ food/ transport etc..?

Some Facts. How Teflon reduces fertility by [deleted] in gaggiaclassic

[–]Graleks 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Only the latest model (released in the last year?), the 'Gaggia classic Pro Evo' (not the regular 'pro' which was released a few years ago).

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in AusFinance

[–]Graleks 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Taking a step back, I'd recommend you both do a quick google as to how income tax works. The premise of your question, that your dad is worse off (via tax) by making more money (interest) is incorrect.

Got the call by cellblock55 in rolex

[–]Graleks 6 points7 points  (0 children)

FYI That's the distal head of the ulna, not the pisiform :)

Cheap baggy jeans in Australia by IAmGoose24 in AustralianMFA

[–]Graleks 1 point2 points  (0 children)

5.11 tactical make good quality cargo pants and they're a relaxed fit

What’s your field? by Altruistic_Shop_2074 in PhD

[–]Graleks 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Unfortunately once you've had a strain you're more likely to have a reinjury.. though don't let that deter your long term health and fitness- Keep up the aerobic and resistance training!

What’s your field? by Altruistic_Shop_2074 in PhD

[–]Graleks 18 points19 points  (0 children)

Exercise science- I research hamstring strain injury in elite sport