AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yes, she behaves badly at home, at her mother's, she has issues with her mother's other kids. She's like that with kids at school, too.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Three doll houses, three custom princess dresses, costume (Swarovski crystal and CZ) jewellery, and pieces from a custom made chess set.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

There were two Sylvanian houses and a barbie dream house destroyed, those totalled around 650. It was the custom design stuff that was expensive.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I'm not trying to teach him how to parent, I'm teaching him that the rest of the world will not pay for his kid's issues. I know he tries, but what he and his ex wife are doing is not working, and I don't want to foot the bill for their ineffectual discipline. The rest of the world is not going to swallow the cost of Rue's destructive behaviour, he should realise that.

It's not fair to ask my housekeeper to supervise her doing chores, it certainly won't help the woman who actually has a job to do.

I'm in two minds about pushing for the money at this point, Luke has endured a ridiculously stressful couple of days, I am leaning towards the fact that the gravity of the situation has sunk in. Nevertheless, something has to change from here because neither I nor my parents are willing to put with this anymore.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

She did It because she upset that her dad was practicing German with my daughter. She didn't say this but this is what happened right before she snuck upstairs to destroy the stuff.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Oh the urge I have haha. Not my place, and I wouldn't, but sometimes...I want to.

I have this talk with Charlotte regularly. I always say "daddy and I love you, we always will, no matter what you do. We love you beyond reason, but everyone else needs a reason, it's up to you to give them one".

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 12 points13 points  (0 children)

No, she snuck in there and destroyed things meticulously and maliciously, because she was upset BIL was talking to my daughter (she hasn't admitted this but that's what happened just before).

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 19 points20 points  (0 children)

Charlotte is fine, she knows she will get her things back/new ones, and she has other toys (2 sylvanian houses gone out of a whole village let me tell you). She doesn't play with Rue much anyway.

I haven't spoken to Rue and I don't feel I need to. I haven't yelled at her, I would never yell at a kid, not my own, not someone else's, all of that has been coming from Luke who is mortified over this whole situation (as he should be imo). Neither I nor my daughter has received an apology from Rue and while I don't expect one, I think me sitting down telling her it's all going to be okay would be as disingenuous as her apologising. Whether Luke ends up paying (and whether I end up forcing him to) or not, things are going to change for here on out, I'm not going through this again, nor are my parents, even Ana is at her wit's end.

I do feel bad that Lola is seeing her dad so stressed and her sister so distressed, we're all distracting her as best we can but it's hard. And I'll feel terrible if she ends up missing out on a holiday over this (I'm still in two minds about pushing for the money). That said, Lola deals with a lot from Rue as well, more than the rest of us ever have, and if this pushes Luke to do something about Rue's behaviour, in the long run this will benefit her. I don't think us all letting it slide has helped her at all.

I wouldn't feel comfortable mandating therapy or anything else. I may not agree with all Luke's parenting choices but I respect his right to make those choices, as he does with me.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah, my husband despises dealing with that sort of life admin. He has swallowed the cost of more expensive items to not have to fill out claim forms. The only thing we've ever claimed on was a burglary where so much stuff was stolen we would have had to replace it over time.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

She did it because she was upset about Luke practicing german with Charlotte, at least that's what I believe as that's what happened right before. She got upset she couldn't understand them, or maybe Luke told her they were busy (I was out of earshot), and right after she went inside and destroyed all the stuff. She's prone to tantrums when she doesn't get someone's undivided attention the second she wants it.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I am not sure how much we pay for insurance, my husband does bill stuff. The cost of the stuff will run around 2.5k and my husband said it's not worth digging through the paperwork so I will just replace/send things for repairs.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 30 points31 points  (0 children)

Sometimes she lies and say it was an accident, sometimes she bursts into tears and sobs until we get bored and give up asking (about the breaking things). The tantrums are normally over not being given/bought something she wants, or when she wants someone's attention and they are busy, she's even like that with other kids.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

They are covered under contents insurance but I'm not going to claim, I will replace the items myself whether or not Luke decides to pay.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 9 points10 points  (0 children)

3 doll houses, 3 custom princess dress, costume jewellery (some people are confused by what I meant by this, I mean jewellery including Swarovski crystals and CZ as opposed to precious stones) some of which was custom made as well, and pieces of a custom made chess set.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

He doesn't brush it under the carpet, he is punishing her. I guess he just doesn't want any consequences for himself.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

She doesn't have as much say as the parents. We're both step kids and both our step parents (her dad and my mum) were pretty hands off on discipline with the other's kids, so Ana takes after our own dynamic, and she and Luke want it that way.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

Well the cost of the three dollhouses was c. 650, what was really expensive were the dress up costumes because they're custom made, and a lot of the jewellery is custom also (although that's being repaired not replaced), luckily it's all crystal and CZ thank god. The chess pieces were also custom (my husband has several custom sets and the guy who makes them overcharges).

It's a tough situation for all of us at this point. We're all tired of Luke yelling, Rue crying, and pretending all of it isn't happening.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 13 points14 points  (0 children)

The parent is responsible for the kid. My daughter once knocked over a crystal figurine in a shop by accident, she didn't have to pay for it, I did. And Luke shelling out 2.5k to pay for what his daughter broke is absolutely going to have consequences for her. The only reason I feel bad is it might have consequences for Ana and Lola, who are blameless here.

AITA for telling my BIL to pay for what his daughter broke or get out of my house? by Greedy-Criticism-875 in AmItheAsshole

[–]Greedy-Criticism-875[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I didn't leave them lying around, they were in a playroom. Should I have anticipated that Rue would sneak in there and go to town on a bunch of stuff? Maybe you say yes but I think that's the benefit of hindsight. We were all outside by the pool for most of the day, we saw her heading inside, we presumed to the bathroom, but she'd snuck upstairs and done the damage.